Finals Week 3 – Geelong v Brisbane: Starcevich

Starcevich
Sometimes the cards don’t fall your way. Our remote home found me too far from half-a-dozen bush pubs to watch Lions Cats. Each one would have provided a different landscape, environment, crowd, texture. These things are important when watching footy.
All that was left was my laptop, in the dark, volume down, so as not to wake the young’un. Flickerings of 93,000, glamour, advertising, glitz, escaping cracks in the blinds, lighting up a mob of grey kangaroos that visits the hills around us regularly.
It was a corker game, with almost everything.
The game started well, once the footy fans choked down their collective rage about umpires these days making it about themselves. The first half of Swans-Port was 100% unwatchable for it. Unwatchable. Hell, the Lions wouldn’t even have been here if not for that bullshit the week before. The Giants were put on a cross by umps showboating.
Fortunately, it was only the Giants. The best jumper by a mile in the AFL, but nobody to barrack for it.
Really, it’s reaching breaking point. I only partly blame the umpires. The League is in their ears, yammering every minute, every second. “Pay it!” “Don’t pay it!” The armchair warriors are judging everything by slow motion replay, in this game of speed and humanity and split-second decisions. Unfortunately, thanks to the internet, they’re the ones the AFL listens to. The bitter, the sooks. The ones who call a bit of harmless banter between a coach and a player, (that most of us LOVED), disgraceful. People that hate rather than love, that barrack against rather than for, that shout; “If So-and-so got three for what he did, this bloke should get five!”, when most of us think neither of them should have gotten anything. That see the funniest piss-take break dance ever, and can’t come up with anything better than; ‘MY TAXES PAID FOR THAT!’, with righteous indignation.
Umps, their bosses, PR people, overstimulated armchair warriors, the press looking to fill columns, and lawyers. Too many voices. One ball. One whistle. It’s a minefield. A shitshow. And it’s not working.
The Cats got a goal early due to said fluff, but after that, thank Christ, the umps mostly found that balance. First time in a while. It was heaven.
It was football.
Geelong looked it early, but finals footy tells us that means nothing. They spend a good ten minutes dominating without once sticking the knife in. It’s all about momentum and defence in finals. How to shift tides that are working against you. Having a team capable of, as a team, readjusting a game plan. The Lions hit back hard, got that swing back, I thought, mostly to big Oscar in the ruck. Doing the first job of a ruckman – hitting it to his teammates.
He popped a shoulder in the second, and changed everything. Stanley got the ball to his smalls, Geelong looked unbeatable. Big Joe was sent to the ruck. Brisbane no longer had their main go-long target.
Those who say rucks are overrated don’t know the game. Not even a little. There was a reason the Geelong wings etc were now running rampant.
That and Tom Stewart. What a champion. I don’t use that word lightly. His timing is almost as good as his patience. Most other backs get sucked up the ground. Not Tom. He hangs back, marks everything, counter attacks like Donkey Kong! It’s not quite one-on-one, but is modern football.
He played the game as if it was his own personal X-Box.
Down the other end, Starcevich was leading the charge. Punching, spoiling, stopping their run, being a finals physical presence. As well as stopping Stengle deader than doornails. Tough, hard running. Everywhere. But Miers was kicking freak goals, then setting up others. Geelong were doing it easy.
Come half time, the Lions put their car over the pits, re-jigging to allow for the loss of Oscar, and Joe being absent from down forward. The half backs brought it through the middle now, rather than down the wings to a tall men contest near the boundary. The new norm, really. Try to pack mark, and if it spills free, the defence are hemmed in by the white line. Ball up, or out of bounds, set up and reload. Stoppages, stoppages. A spoilt mark from the lead up the guts is deadly to you on the rebound! Defenders are now so good at running, a few links and you’ve gone from being in your 50 to being in big trouble.
Leading up the guts, the other mob can run from everywhere.
Geelong steadied, but now the Lions were sharing the load beautifully. The game was hanging in the balance worse than the final scene of The Italian Job – or, for the next generation, its rip-off, Lock Stock and Two Smoking Barrels.
Enter Rayner. He looks like a tough bastard, but hasn’t delivered in finals. Not nearly. He took hangers, and finished off goals created by running half backs and was everywhere. The cause of a run, or the result of one, irrelevant.
The Lions had the sweetness of momentum gods favouring them, and Geelong had no-one grabbing it back by the short and curlies.
Joe, for all his heart and character, is clearly not a ruckman, yet Stanley stopped monstering this fact. He won hitouts, but now rarely down the throat of anyone. Such a waste. Why? Tired, injured. How good is he? Cometh the hour, surely, cometh the man…
If he’s got it.
Charging through the last, Henry kept Geelong in it, but Starcevich once more upped the volume. He covered all points. Stengle was nowhere.
Andrews shut down Cameron when it mattered most. When the game was there for winning. Danger was good without seizing it. They all were. Only Rayner took it to the next level.
Rayner, and, I thought, Hipwood. Poor ol’ Hipwwod. Ragged out by everyone, always. With Joe gone he was everywhere, contesting on the wing when the Lions had no targets, leading through half forward, charging up the other wing. Unlike Cameron, who got a few easy ones down back, Hipwood didn’t have a Henry staying home. It was up to him. Just him. To be everywhere. If he didn’t bring it to ground, Tom Stewart and Jack Henry would have marked it and rebounded and done their whole Geelong thing. Hipwood saved the game, absolutely.
The last five minutes reeked of a set-up for Greek tragedy. The Lions held a lead that bounced around 1.5. Never quite two goals. The door ajar for one-point miracles.
First, Duncan was running in, 20 out, and Payne turned an average game into a forever moment, with a tackle that gets entire states into Grand Finals. If the mob of maroon and blue is going apey this time next week, all good backmen the world over will ignore whichever pretty-boy is getting the Norm, and remember that moment and nod to no-one and each other, as they sigh easily.
Then Stanley had his chance to feed that one-point beast. He got a soft-but-there free after fluffing a ruckman’s breakfast (easy mark), was given a shot from 15 out, dead-enough in front, 41 seconds to go – more than enough time to get the goal then launch again from the middle and squeeze through the stuff of legends.
And he missed it.
Game over.
When he was walking in for his shot it seemed all of Fate was leaning towards two Cats majors in under a minute.
They say nobody remembers the Prelim finalists. That’s bullshit. The fans do. The clubs do. The recruiters and sponsor officers do, most assuredly. “We’re close.” “Come over to us.” “Stay with us.” The players do, absolutely! Prelims hold more life-long nightmares than grand finals.
And often more highlights.
The game was the guts. Speckies, great goals, lead shifts, drama… All it lacked to really be one for the ages, I thought, was a dominant forward. One who made the whole crowd scared or excited every time the ball went near him. A lead-up player, tall or small, charging at the pill, rather than away from it. It needed a Hawkins, a Johnno Brown, even a Toby Green. A Bobby Hill, turning it on from the git-go. But why get greedy?
A backman, Starcevich, was clearly best on ground. The ‘experts’ who give their ratings only to then back them up with stats can shove them up their Khyber. They can go to hell. Presence, finals presence, you can’t buy it, bottle it, or find it on a stats sheet. Starca had and gave everything.
Forwards, even if former champions in the media box, often miss these things.
Brisbane did it, two matches in a row, through will to win, force of personality. Through team discipline. The ability, collectively, to change tack and stick to it. Worthy grand finalists, having survived a corker.
All that’s left from here, is the pure joy of watching South Melbourne take on Fitzroy for the decider.
No laptops for that. Sacrilege! I’ll make sure wherever it is, there’ll be people, fans going loopy!
GEELONG 1.5 8.7 10.8 12.13 (85)
BRISBANE 3.2 5.6 10.10 14.11 (95)
GOALS
Geelong: O.Henry 4, Cameron 2, Miers 2, Mannagh, Dempsey, Dangerfield, Blicavs,
Brisbane: Ah Chee 3, Rayner 2, Cameron 2, Bailey 2, Morris 2, Hipwood, McCluggage, Lohmann
BEST
Geelong: Holmes, Dangerfield, Stewart, Miers, O.Henry
Brisbane: Lohmann, Neale, McCluggage, Starcevich, Zorko, Bailey
INJURIES
Geelong: Holmes (left hamstring), J.Henry (right ankle)
Brisbane: McInerney (left shoulder)
SUBSTITUTES
Geelong: Mitch Duncan (replaced Max Holmes in the last quarter)
Brisbane: Conor McKenna (replaced Oscar McInerney in the third quarter)
Crowd: 93,066 at the MCG
Read more from Matt Zurbo HERE
To return to The Footy Almanac home page click HERE
Our writers are independent contributors. The opinions expressed in their articles are their own. They are not the views, nor do they reflect the views, of Malarkey Publications.
Do you enjoy the Almanac concept?
And want to ensure it continues in its current form, and better? To help keep things ticking over please consider making your own contribution.
Become an Almanac (annual) member – CLICK HERE

bleh












Matt,
As usual your insights are distinctive but spot on. Another aspect of Starcevich’s performance which I thought noteworthy was that he had a disappointing Grand Final last year, when Bobby Hill took him to the cleaners. In Starchevich’s defence, Hill, in the mood he was in on GF day would have been a handful for the finest defenders. Often players struggle however to overcome the memory of a “failure” on the biggest stage.
What a game, what a great match report too. Definitely agree that that Starce was our best. The loss of Big O was and remains hard to countenance for this week. Geelong looked enormous after he went off. Thanks for a wonderful write up of a game I want to remember
Cracking write up Matt. Brilliant game in a finals series & season that’s been – meh. Too many athletes & game plans. Not enough footballers & smarts. But when they come together like this it’s blitzkrieg ballet. Callum Ah Chee doesn’t get a lot of recognition. Team player – smart forward with good defensive skills.
Great write up old dog totally agree re GWS being the victim of Hollywood umpiring – as a experienced maggot umpiring is putrid due to horrendous coaching and diabolical instructions given.A ruckman who can give there mids 1st – clean possession and a real hit out to advantage ( not the idiotic way they are recorded so a hit out and hacked kick forward that is recorded as to advantage is bullshit ) Starcevich stitching up Stengle and Hipwood competing you nailed it ! Agree with PB Callum Ah Chee is vital thanks OD
Thanks to all. Good points. Yeah. Ah Chee does great. Love the way he flies under the radar, no stupid posey, look-at-me flexes after goals. Just does the job.
Love it, Old Dog.
That game fizzed and popped like a cauldron of fireworks.
I barely know any players by name these days but I loved how Brizzy found another way after their ruckman was lost. They had to.
And I loved how they kept using the centre of the ground. Opened it up.
As if saying “if we’re good enough, we’ll win.”
It reminded me of the way the pies played through a lot of 2023.
Play on.
Ripper piece, mate That was a game for the ages and you took me right back there. Swans, watch out for those Brisbane small/medium forwards.
Great stuff and thanks OD. Agree about the umpires, week before in Port v Hawthorn, the wees and poos got their first 3 goals from diabolical decisions, in my view. Also in my view, the best thing the AFL could do would be to remove the microphones from them. Love the line about old defenders sitting around muttering about those softies up forward, reminds me of some lines years ago about front rowers in rugby union sitting in “the sheds” after games, muttering among themselves. Love to be a fly on the wall.
Anyway, much enjoyed and thanks.
Thanks Matt, great read on a great match.
It was an absolute ripper of a match.
Thanks OD. While I’m completely disinterested in a twilight grand final, I’m a huge fan of the Saturday preliminary final at this time. It was a remarkable game with such a catalogue of great moments!