Almanac Teams: Arrivals and Departures (Melbourne)

 

 

This year for football teams I have gone back to a theme. A team of Arrivals and Departures at each club. I hope the teams go down well.

 

The criteria for each team

  • Based each team of players from 1980 onwards;
  • Have tried to put a player in from each of the remaining 18 teams, including Fitzroy on most occasions;
  • Have tried to be as balanced as possible, though the interchange regardless of balance will be next best four players;
  • The player is based on from previous club and to immediate next club;
  • Stats are based on the club and for arrivals, the immediate club before and for departures, the immediate club after;
  • The Arrivals team is based on the performance at the club, while departures is based on the performance at their new club.

 

If I’ve missed anyone, please advise, and please enjoy.

 

The highlights of the team are 16 players from North Melbourne to Melbourne but only one player went the other way. Of the 16, seven of them were coached by Ron Barassi at both clubs. The defence especially the talls are the strength of the arrivals while midfield is the strength of the departures.

 

 

Peter Moore [Source: Author]

 

ARRIVALS

FB:          Jamie Duursma (Bris)          Jamie Shanahan (St.K)        Shane Zantuck (SM)

 

CHB:       Michael Hibberd (Ess)         Steven May (VC) (GCS)       Marcus Seecamp (Fitz)

 

C:             Stephen Powell (WB)           Brian Wilson (NM)               Bernie Vince (Adel)

 

CHF:       Byron Pickett (PA)                Ben Holland (Rich)               Dom Tyson (GWS)

 

FF:           Jeff Garlett (Carl)                 Darren Bennett (WCE)         Jeff White (Freo)

 

Ruck:      Peter  Moore (C) (Coll)        Jordan Lewis (Haw)              Brent Moloney (Geel)

 

Interchange: Steven Icke (NM), Ed Langdon (Freo), Jake Lever (Adel), Jake Melksham (Ess)

 

Sub: Clint Bizzell (Geel)

 

 

Jamie Duursma –  1 game Bris (1987) and 33 games Melb (1988-1989)

Jamie Shanahan – 125 games St.K (1992-1997) and 37 games Melb (1998-1999)

Shane Zantuck – 56 games SM (1977-1980) and 88 games Melb (1981-1986)

Michael Hibberd – 84 games Ess (2011-2015) and 113 games Melb (2017-2023)

Steven May – 123 games GCS (2011-2018) and 106 games Melb (2019- )

Marcus Seecamp – 41 games Fitz (1992-1994) and 99 games Melb (1995-2000)

Stephen Powell – 30 games WB (1997-1999) and 44 games Melb (2000-2002)

Brian Wilson – 39 games NM (1980-1981) and 154 games Melb (1982-1990)

Bernie Vince – 129 games Adel (2006-2013) and 100 games Melb (2014-2018)

Byron Pickett – 55 games PA (2003-2005) and 29 games Melb (2006-2007)

Ben Holland – 125 games Rich (1996-2003) and 66 games Melb (2004-2008)

Dom Tyson – 13 games GWS (2012-2013) and 94 games Melb (2014-2018)

Jeff Garlett – 107 games Carl (2009-2014) and 78 games Melb (2015-2019)

Darren Bennett – 4 games WCE (1987) and 74 games Melb (1989-1993)

Jeff White – 32 games Freo (1995-1997) and 236 games Melb (1998-2008)

Peter Moore – 172 games Coll (1974-1982) and 77 games Melb (1983-1987)

Jordan Lewis – 264 games Haw (2005-2016) and 55 games Melb (2017-2019)

Brent Moloney – 23 games Geel (2003-2004) and 122 games Melb (2005-2012)

Steven Icke – 120 games NM (1975-1981) and 78 games Melb (1982-1987)

Ed Langdon – 68 games Freo (2015-2019) and 102 games Melb (2020- )

Jake Lever – 56 games Adel (2015-2017) and 114 games Melb (2018- )

Jake Melksham – 114 games Ess (2010-2015) and 107 games Melb (2016- )

Clint Bizzell – 75 games Geel (1996-2001) and 88 games Melb (2002-2007)

 

 

 

 

Others

 

Matthew Collins (14 games Adel 1996-1997 and 29 games Melb 1998-2001), Anthony Ingerson (37 games Adel 1992-1995 and 121 games Melb 1996-2001), Shane McAdam (50 games Adel 2019-2023 and 1 games Melb 2024- ), John Meesen (2 games Adel 2007 and 4 games Melb 2009), Nick Pesch (31 games Adel 1994-1996 and 4 games Melb 1997), Aiden Riley (12 games Adel 2011-2013 and 13 games Melb 2014-2015), James Sellar (21 games Adel 2008-2011 and 23 games Melb 2012-2013), Peter Vardy (96 games Adel 1996-2001 and 41 games Melb 2002-2004)

 

Nick Carter (22 games Bris 1996-1998 and 3 games Melb 1999), Mitch Clark (82 games Bris 2006-2011 and 15 games Melb 2012-2013), Joel MacDonald (80 games Bris 2004-2009 and 44 games Melb 2010-2013)

 

Vin Catoggio (71 games Carl 1973-1980 and 9 games Melb 1981-1982), Phil Pinnell (173 games Carl 1969-1979 and 28 games Melb 1980-1981), Peter Rohde (46 games Melb 1985-1987 and 117 games Carl 1988-1995), Michael Young (37 games Carl 1977-1980 and 15 games Melb 1981-1982)

 

Chris Dawes (71 games Coll 2008-2012 and 50 games Melb 2013-2016), Brodie Grundy (177 games Coll 2013-2022 and 17 games Melb 2023), Ben Kennedy (25 games Coll 2013-2015 and 15 games Melb 2016), Heritier Lumumba (199 games Coll 2005-2014 and 24 games Melb 2015-2016), Stephen Pitt (13 games Coll 1996 and 5 games Melb 2000-2001), Robert Pyman (5 games Coll 1996 and 19 games Melb 1997), Dannie Seow (18 games Coll 1986-1987 and 7 games Melb 1989-1990)

 

Mitch Brown (55 games Ess 2016-2019 and 9 games Melb 2020-2022), Steven Clark (53 games Ess 1985-1989 and 21 games Melb 1990-1991), Chris Heffernan (97 games Ess 1997-2002 and 47 games Melb 2003-2005), Peter Keenan (31 games Ess 1979-1980 and 30 games Melb 1981-1982), Gary Moorcroft (95 games Ess 1995-2002 and 3 games Melb 2003), Trevor Spencer (31 games Ess 1985-1989 and 3 games Melb 1990-1991)

 

Stuart Cameron (13 games Fitz 1986-1988 and 5 games Melb 1990), Daryl Cox (16 games Fitz 1980-1983 and 13 games Melb 1984-1986), Les Parish (87 games Fitz 1980-1985 and 7 games Melb 1985)

 

Harley Bennell (2 games Freo 2017 and 5 games Melb 2020), Scott Chisholm (63 games Freo 1995-1998 and 18 games Melb 1999-2000), Viv Michie (1 game Freo 2013 and 21 games Melb 2014-2016)

 

Shannon Byrnes (108 games Geel 2004-2012 and 23 games Melb 2013-2014), Tom Gillies (13 games Geel 2019-2012 and 2 games Melb 2013), Nigel Kol (2 games Geel 1983 and 28 games Melb 1985-1987)

 

Kade Kolodjasnij (78 games GCS 2014-2018 and 2 games Melb 2019)

 

Thomas Bugg (65 games GWS 2012-2015 and 31 games Carl 2016-2018), Sam Frost (21 games GWS 2012-2014 and 70 games Melb 2015-2019), Adam Tomlinson (140 games GWS 2012-2019 and 41 games Melb 2020-)

 

David Flintoff (1 games Haw 1983 and 31 games Melb 1988-1991)

 

Ben Brown (130 games NM 2014-2020 and 45 games Melb 2021- ), Paul Bryce (48 games NM 1987-1990 and 26 games Melb 1991-1992), Alistair Clarkson (93 games NM 1987-1995 and 41 games Melb 1996-1997),  Brent Crosswell (76 games NM 1975-1979 and 48 games Melb 1980-1982), Alan Jarrott (91 games NM 1977-1981 and 79 games Melb 1979-1982), Doug Koop (5 games NM 1985-1986 and 22 games Melb 1987-1988), Shannon Motlop (55 games NM 1999-2003 and 11 games Melb 2005-2006), Bill Nettlefold (51 games NM 1976-1979 and 54 games Melb 1980-1982), Cameron Pederson (16 games NM 2011-2012 and 64 games Melb 2013-2018), Braydon Preuss (8 games NM 2017 and 10 games Melb 2019-2020), Shaun Smith (47 games NM 1987-1992 and 62 games Melb 1995-1998), Xavier Tanner (100 games NM 1976-1983 and 11 games Melb 1984-1985), Corey Wagner (8 games NM 2016-2017 and 11 games Melb 2019), Rodney Wright (22 games NM 1980-1982 and 32 games Melb 1983-1996)

 

Ben Newton (4 games PA 2014 and 13 games Melb 2015-2016), David Rodan (111 games PA 2007-2012 and 9 games Melb 2013)

 

Phil Egan (125 games Rich 1982-1990 and 1 game Melb 1991), Ross Funcke (27 games Rich 1996-1999 and 15 games Melb 2000-2001), Andy Goodwin (56 games Rich 1987-1993 and 17 games Melb 1992-1993), Michael Pickering (136 games Rich 1984-1991 and 15 games Melb 1992-1993)

 

Jack Billings (155 games St.K 2014-2023 and 11 games Melb 2024- ), Greg Doyle (2 games St.K 1990 and 29 games Melb 1993-1996), Luke Dunstan (116 games St.K 2014-2021 and 5 games Melb 2022), David Grant (191 games St.K 1984-1995 and 7 games Melb 1996), Jeff Hilton (6 games St.K 1991-1992 and 43 games Melb 1994-1996), Peter Kiel (80 games St.K 1982-1986 and 1 game Melb 1987), Rod Owen (60 games St.K 1983-1990 and 9 games Melb 1991)

 

Wayne Henwood (78 games Syd 1987-1991 and 1 games Melb 1992), Craig Nettelbeck (45 games Syd 1990-1994 and 33 games Melb 1996-1997)

 

Dean Irving (43 games WCE 1990-1993 and 23 games Melb 1994-1997), Paul Johnson (1 games WCE 2003 and 68 games Melb 2005-2010, Phillip Read (74 games WCE 1998-2003 and 34 games Melb 2004-2006, Craig Turley (115 games WCE 1989-1995 and 16 games Melb 1996)

 

Adrian Campbell (30 games Foots 1988-1992 and 2 games Melb 1993), Dean Chiron (1 games Foots 1986 and 17 games Melb 1987-1989), James Cook (49 games WB 1996-1999 and 3 games Melb 2000), Daniel Cross (210 games WB 2002-2013 and 39 games Melb 2014-2015) , Craig Ellis (107 games WB 1994-2001 and 15 games Melb 2002), Lachlan Hunter (173 games WB 2013-2022 and 26 games Melb 2023- ), Josh Schache (45 games WB 2018-2022 and 4 games Melb 2023- ), Kelvin Templeton (143 games Foots 1974-1982 and 34 games Melb 1983-1985)

 

Earl Spalding [Source: Author]

 

DEPARTURES

FB:           Jared Rivers (Geel)              Tony Campbell (Foots)                   Matthew Warnock (GCS)

 

CHB:       John Howat (Rich)               Matthew Bishop (PA)                     Martin Pike (Fitz)

 

C:             Stephen Powell (St.K)          Scott Thompson (VC) (Adel)        Tom Scully (GWS)

 

CHF:       Jeremy Howe (Coll)             Earl Spalding (Carl)                        Dom Tyson (NM)

 

FF:           Tony Elshaug (Ess)              Michael Byrne (Haw)                     Jeff Farmer (Freo)

 

Ruck:       Stefan Martin (Bris)            Gerard Healy (C) (Syd)                  Andy Lovell (WCE)

 

Interchange: James Frawley (Haw), Darren Jolly (Syd), Brock McLean (Carl), Greg Wells (Carl)

 

Sub:      Jason Norrish (Freo)

 

 

 

Jared Rivers – 150 games Melb 2003-2012 and 44 games Geel 2013-2015

Tony Campbell – 75 games Melb 1986-1991 and 43 games NM 1992-1994

Matthew Warnock – 55 games Melb 2008-2011 and 32 games GCS 2012-2014

John Howat – 20 games Melb 1989-1992 and 45 games Rich 1993-1996

Matthew Bishop – 18 games Melb 1998-1999 and 132 PA 2000-2006

Martin Pike – 24 games Melb 1993-1994 and 36 games Fitz 1995-1996

Stephen Powell – 44 games Melb 2000-2002 and 68 games St.K 2003-2006

Scott Thompson – 39 games Melb 2001-2004 and 269 games Adel 2005-2017

Tom Scully – 31 games Melb 2010-2011 and 121 games GWS 2012-2018

Jeremy Howe – 100 games Melb 2011-2015 and 144 games Coll 2016-

Earl Spalding – 109 games Melb 1987-1991 and 102 games Carl 1992-1997

Dom Tyson –  94 games Melb 2014-2018 and 6 games NM 2019-21

Tony Elshaug – 66 games Melb 1979-1983 and 65 games Ess 1984-1987

Michael Byrne – 56 games Melb 1977-1982 and 90 games Haw 1982-1986

Jeff Farmer –  118 games Melb 1995-2001 and 131 games Freo 2002-2008

Stefan Martin – 57 games Melb 2008-2012 and 133 games Bris 2013-20

Gerard Healy – 130 games Melb 1978-1985 and 81 games Syd 1986-1990

Andy Lovell – 121 games Melb 1988-1995 and 43 games WCE 1996-1998

James Frawley – 139 games Melb 2007-2014 and 100 games Haw 2015-20

Darren Jolly – 48 games Melb 2001-2004 and 118 games Syd 2005-2009

Brock McLean – 94 games Melb 2004-2009 and 63 games Carl 2010-2014

Greg Wells – 224 games Melb 1969-1980 and 43 games Carl 1980-1982

Jason Norrish – 20 games Melb 1992-1994 and 128 games Freo 1995-2002

 

 

 

 

Others

 

Danny Hughes (124 games Melb 1984-1990 and 11 games Adel 1991), Trent Ormond-Allen (8 games Melb 1995-1996 and 42 games Adel 1997-1999), Clay Sampson (13 games Melb 1995-1996 and 24 games Adel 1997-1998)

 

Daryl Cox (13 games Melb 1984-1986 and 1 game Bris 1987), David Dickson (56 games Melb 1982-1986 and 30 games Bris 1987-1989), John Fidge (32 games Melb 1984-1986 and 27 games Bris 1987-1989), Fabian Francis (1 game Melb 1991 and 22 games Bris 1993-1994), Travis Johnstone (160 games Melb 1998-2007 and 49 games Bris 2008-2010), Brent Moloney (122 games Melb 2005-2012 and 21 games Bris 2013-2014), Rod Owen (9 game Melb 1991 and 9 games Bris 1992), Mark Withers (32 games Melb 1984-1986 and 36 games Bris 1987-1990)

 

Sean Charles (47 games Melb 1992-1997 and 1 game Carl 1998), Brent Heaver (12 games Melb 1990-1991 and 64 games Carl 1992-1996), Chris Johnson (25 games Melb 2005-2008 and 21 games Carl 2009-2010), Oscar McDonald (81 games Melb 2015-2020 and 5 games Carl 2021-2022), Paul Payne (28 games Melb 1985-1988 and 5 games Carl 1989)

 

Simon Buckley (21 games Melb 2007-2009 and 26 games Coll 2011-2012), Lynden Dunn (165 games Melb 2006-2016 and 33 games Coll 2017-2020), Glenn McLean (42 games Melb 1980-1984 and 2 games Coll 1984), Shane Woewodin (138 games Melb 1997-2002 and 62 games Coll 2003-2005)

 

Phil Carman (11 games Melb 1979 and 10 games Ess 1980-1981), Cameron Clayton (44 games Melb 1979-1982 and 17 games Ess 1983), Chris Heffernan (47 games Melb 2003-2005 and 26 games Ess 2006-2007), Mark Jamar (155 games Melb 2003-2015 and 5 games Ess 2016), Paul O’Brien (22 games Melb 1980-1983 and 3 Ess 1988), Michael O’Sullivan (53 games Melb 1982-1986 and 1 game Ess 1988), Sam Weideman (59 games Melb 2016-2022 and 16 games Ess 2023- )

 

Tom Kavanagh (2 games Melb 1989 and 8 games Fitz 1993-1994), Wayne Lamb (2 games Melb 1992 and 19 games Fitz 1995-1996), Darren Louttit (13 games Melb 1985-1986 and 2 games Fitz 1988), Steven Stretch (164 games Melb 1986-1993 and 25 games Fitz 1994-1995)

 

Phil Gilbert (25 games Melb 1993-1994 and 14 games Freo 1995-1996), Jesse Hogan (71 games Melb 2015-2018 and 19 games Freo 2019-2020), Luke Jackson (52 games Melb 2020-2022 and 37 games Freo 2023- ), Troy Longmuir (12 games Melb 1998-1999 and 55 games Freo 2000-2004), Troy Simmonds (40 games Melb 1999-2001 and 64 games Freo 2002-2004), Colin Sylvia (154 games Melb 2004-2013 and 4 games Freo 2014), Corey Wagner (11 games Melb 2019 and 9 games Freo 2023- )

 

Bret Bailey (86 games Melb 1984-1989 and 1 game Geel 1990), Sam Blease (33 games Melb 2011-2014 and 1 game Geel 2015), Mitch Clark (15 games Melb 2012-2013 and 9 games Geel 2015-2016), Brent Grgic (77 games Melb 1997-2001 and 13 games Geel 2002-2003), Trevor Spencer (3 games Melb 1990-1991 and 10 games Geel 1991)

 

Toby Bedford (18 games Melb 2020-2022 and 33 games GWS 2023- ), James McDonald (251 games Melb 1997-2010 and 13 games GWS 2012), Braydon Preuss (10 games Melb 2019-2020 and 10 games GWS 2022- )

 

Cameron Bruce (224 games Melb 2000-2010 and 10 games Haw 2011-2012), Kyle Cheney (14 games Melb 2009-2010 and 27 games Haw 2011-2014), Roger Ellingworth (41 games Melb 1981-1984 and 1 games Haw 1986), Jack Fitzpatrick (22 games Melb 2011-2015 and 4 games Haw 2016-2017), Sam Frost (70 games Melb 2015-2019 and 82 games Haw 2020- ), Paul Johnson (68 Melb 2005-2010 and 1 game Haw 2011)

 

Dom Barry (5 games Melb 2014 and 5 games PA 2018), Jimmy Toumpas (27 games Melb 2013-2015 and 10 games PA 2016-2017), Jack Trengove (86 games Melb 2010-2017 and 3 games PA 2018), Peter Walsh (104 games Melb 1999-2004 and 35 games PA 2005-2006), Jack Watts (153 games Melb 2009-2017 and 21 games PA 2018-2019)

 

Simon Eishold (77  games Melb 1986-1992 and 5 games Rich 1993), Addam Maric (21 games Melb 2008-2011 and 10 games Rich 2012), Brad Miller (133 games Melb 2002-2010 and 24 games Rich 2011-2012), Steven O’Dwyer (84 games Melb 1987-1991 and 5 games Rich 1992), Ricky Pettard (54 games Melb 2007-2012 and 30 games Rich 2013-2015), Haydn Robins (20 games Melb 1992-1993 and 4 games Rich 1994), Chris Sullivan (27 games Melb 1992-1994 and 8 games Rich 1995-1996), Scott Sutcliffe (7 games Melb 1982-1983 and 2 games Rich 1986)

 

Glenn Boland (16 games Melb 1983-1984 and 3 games St.K 1985), Steven Clark (21 games Melb 1990-1991 and 6 games St.K 1992), Mark Jackson (41 games Melb 1981-1982 and 10 games St.K 1983), Dean Kent (63 games Melb 2013-2018 and 37 games St.K 2019-2022), Rodney Keogh (22 games Melb 1990-1993 and 60 games St.K 1994-1998), Steven Newport (101 games Melb 1985-1990 and 39 games Melb 1991-1993), Steven Turner (32 games Melb 1986-1987 and 12 games St.K 1988-1989), Brian Wilson (154 games Melb 1982-1990 and 7 games 1991)

 

Garry Baker (127 games Melb 1974-1981 and 6 games Syd 1983), Adrian Battiston (96 games Melb 1982-1987 and 9 games Syd 1988-1989), Paul Bryce (26 games Melb 1991-1992 and 17 games Syd 1993), Vin Catoggio (9 games Melb 1981-1982 and 8 games Syd 1983), David Cordner (53 games Melb 1982-1987 and 5 games Syd 1988), Kevin Dyson (70 games Melb 1991-1995 and 35 games Syd 1996-1997), Brodie Grundy (17 games Melb 2023 and 14 games Syd 2024- ), James Jordan (65 games Melb 2021-2023 and 14 games Syd 2024- )

 

Steven Armstrong (43 games Melb 2002-2005 and 36 games WCE 2006-2008), Jamie Bennell (57 games Melb 2009-2012 and 30 games WCE 2014-2016), Jayden Hunt (114 games Melb 2016-2022 and 34 games WCE 2023- ), Cale Morton (73 games Melb 2008-2012 and 3 games WCE 2013)

 

David Allday (15 games Melb 1985-1986 and 6 games Foots 1988), Oskar Baker (15 games Melb 2019-2021 and 23 games WB 2023- ), Les Bamblett (11 games Melb 1983 and 37 games Foots 1984-1988), Jamie Barham (4 games Melb 1981 and 1 game Foots 1982), Mitch Hannan (50 games Melb 2017-2021 and 30 games WB 2021-2023), James Harmes (152 games Melb 2015-2023 and 8 games WB 2024- ), Allen Jakovich (47 games Melb 1991-1994 and 7 games Foots 1996)

 

 

 

To return to our Footy Almanac home page click HERE.

 

Our writers are independent contributors. The opinions expressed in their articles are their own. They are not the views, nor do they reflect the views, of Malarkey Publications.

 

 

Do you enjoy the Almanac concept?

And want to ensure it continues in its current form, and better? To help things keep ticking over please consider making your own contribution.

 

Become an Almanac (annual) member – click HERE.

 

Comments

  1. Jarrod_L says

    Extraordinary Roos and Dees traffic there Rodney – has there been many other pairs of clubs you’ve noticed with lopsided lists?

  2. Heaps of research done there – a good job and most informative.

  3. Thanks Jarrod & Fisho

    Closest Jarrod I can see is Carlton 7 gains to St Kilda is 17

Leave a Comment

*