Book Review: ‘Lament’ by Nicole Kelly


When Muhammed Ali opened the 1996 Olympics in Atlanta a commentator remarked that the former boxer was, ‘the most famous man in the world’, and safely on my beanbag in front of the box I scoffed at the notion before later deciding it was likely true. His deeds, both noble and otherwise, continue to generate their own global momentum, and with a mythic, omnipresent station in Australian life Ned Kelly makes a similar, albeit local, impact.


While I’m not a Kelly obsessive some contextual experiences include Sidney Nolan’s Ned Kelly series which I first encountered at high school. These were intriguing and disturbing, and I knew there must be substantial reasons for the artist to complete 27 paintings on this subject although at seventeen I was naïve to their deeper reverberations. Around the turn of the millennium I read Peter Carey’s True History of the Kelly Gang and found it hypnotic, and I’m a huge admirer of Midnight Oil’s, ‘If Ned Kelly Was King’ (from their superb Place Without a Postcard) with its speculation on how our most iconic bushranger would handle modern multinationals.


With this literary and artistic baggage in hand I read Nicole Kelly’s Lament in this luxurious week between Christmas and New Year (this year’s ham intake has been down, oddly but healthily), and given the holiday freedom from tyrannical bosses that some of us are enjoying I’m sure Ned would’ve approved of my recreation. ‘Lament’ is a compelling text and the plot races along with the thrill and constant danger of an escaping bushranger’s stallion. The novel’s a balance of exterior action and, as a first person narrative, Ned’s acutely human interior. He’s also a charismatic leader of his gang


‘Pistols out, lads. Be ready for any bolters. We can’t have work out yet.’ I carry one in each hand. ‘We’re takin’ no prisoners. So give ‘em a warning and if there’s any movement, ye cut ‘em down, ye hear me?’ (Page 79)


The central purpose of ‘Lament’ is to wonder what might’ve happened if the Kelly Gang escaped Glenrowan, and this speculative fiction imagines how they hope to live once their bushranging days are done. So sympathetically, so abundantly does Nicole Kelly chaperone us into the private world of the central character that despite his inexcusable violence I found myself cheering for Ned, and his gang’s escape into happy, anonymous lives. As our narrator he observes carefully and with a native, attractive intellect


I warm to the two of them and it is her nickname, affectionately called, that confirms the great luck of my acquaintance with the couple. She’s another beautiful and formidable Kate within my life now. I think of my sister, who has always had my back. These people, so familiar and yet so strange, circling in my life. Surely, if I rely on a Kate, I am in good hands. (Page 146)


In this reimagining the character of Ettie gives symbolic and real agency to those frequently marginalised in this story of the marginalised. While it remains Ned’s version of events Ettie and other females like Anne Jones, the Glenrowan Inn proprietor, are given due prominence in this retelling and this is a strength of the writing.


Ned Kelly looms over our collective consciousness because, rightly or wrongly, he’s become the national embodiment of the themes of injustice and inevitable doom, but also love for family which have found forceful expression in this publication. With our sense of what it means to be Australian under heightened and probing scrutiny, this novel is most timely. I enjoyed my excursion into this historical domain of dark and light, and the chance to reflect upon a man who remains emblematic of much of our national identity.


Simultaneously of its time, but also distinctly modern in authorial attitude and style, Nicole Kelly has given us a new and welcome perspective on this infamous life.


Lament can be  purchased by contacting  or you can visit to contact her.


To return to the  home page click HERE


Our writers are independent contributors. The opinions expressed in their articles are their own. They are not the views, nor do they reflect the views, of Malarkey Publications.


Do you enjoy the Almanac concept?
And want to ensure it continues in its current form, and better? To help keep things ticking over please consider making your own contribution.


Become an Almanac (annual) member – CLICK HERE
One-off financial contribution – CLICK HERE
Regular financial contribution (monthly EFT) – CLICK HERE




About Mickey Randall

Favourite film: The Shawshank Redemption Favourite song: Khe Sahn Favourite holiday destination: Gold Coast Favourite food: steak Favourite beer: VB Best player seen: Dogga Worst player seen: Frogga Last score on beep test: 3.14159 Favourite minor character in Joyce’s Ulysses: Punch Costello


  1. A fine review, Mickey. (You beat me to it, actually).

    As someone who was always fascinated by the Kelly story, I read “Lament” a few weeks ago, and found it to be thoroughly enjoyable. The nuance in the language and dialogue was a highlight, and really stuck with me.

    Well done Nicole, your book is a fine addition to the Kelly pantheon. Carey’s “True History of the Kelly Gang” is one of the best books I have ever read, and Robert Drewe’s “Our Sunshine” was almost as good.

  2. Thanks Smokie. Researching for this review I was staggered by the volume of books on Ned Kelly, both fictional and otherwise. Some of the speculative titles look astonishing! Of course, I reckon a zombie apocalypse film starring NK must be soon on its way.

  3. Mickey, over the years I have red numerous books and seen many films on the life of Ned Kelly. One of the very best is MONTY WEDDS graphic novel about the famous bushranger. Monty researched, pencilled and inked the story and was very meticulous in his take on the legend – very close as to what really happened. In his life time, Monty ran an Australiana museum in NSW. I recommenced to any one interested in Kelly’s life. In my humble opinion it’s quite special.

  4. Thanks Fisho. What a rich well this is. I note there’s a book called Whatever Happened to Ned Kelly’s Head?

  5. Nicole Kelly says

    Thanks for the lovely review, Mickey! I’m glad that you enjoyed it. I love that week between Christmas and New Year…I had the pages turning during these days as well!

  6. Well done Nicole. I anticipate your next publication! I’ll get a good chance to continue reading this week too (between swimming, cricket, pub visits and assorted activities) up at Barmera as I’m part way through Thomas Mann’s Magic Mountain.

    Thanks again.

Leave a Comment