Almanac Teams: Debuts with different happenings/milestones!
My first AFL team for 2025 is based on unusual or different debuts.
The team is not based on what the players listed but the unusual circumstances of their debut or what happened on their debut.
I have not listed players that played in the clubs first games as there was multiple players or players that debut in finals.
Please feel free to name any more as I am sure I have forgotten some.
Once again like past years this team is from 1980 but am happy to hear of earlier correspondence.
FB Paul Duffield (Frem) Leo Barry (Syd) Peter Melesso (SM)
CHB Jack Hutchins (GCS) Ray Hall (Rich) Jason Wild (Coll)
CE Ed Allan (Coll) Rick Norman (NM) Glenn Bowyer (Haw)
CHF Jeff Bruce (Fitz) Brett Chalmers (Adel) Mark Foyster (St.K)
FF Jacob Heron (GCS) Jay Neagle (Ess) Con Gorozidis (St.K)
RU Nic Naitanui (WCE) Justin Blumfield (Ess) Darren Collins (Coll)
Inter Peter Curtain (St. K), Jack Fitzpatrick (Melb), Michael Schulze (Gee) Clinton Wolf (Frem)
Sub Alastair Lord (Ess)
Emg Changkouth Jiath (Haw), Brodie Murdoch (St. K), Dean Polo (Rich), Nick Trask (Bne)
Paul Duffield – Round 5 v St. Kilda 2006 (171 Games Fremantle 2006-2015)
Duffield’s debut was at York Park Launceston in the infamous Sirengate match. This match was when Fremantle led by a point at the final siren, but the umpires never heard it and play continued with St Kilda scoring a point to draw the match. Four days later the AFL commission stripped St Kilda of the point and awarded the match to Fremantle.
Leo Barry – Round 22 v Collingwood 1995 (237 Games Sydney 1995-2009)
This would be Ron Barassi’s last of 482 games as Coach of Carlton, North Melbourne, Melbourne and Sydney. Barassi would sign off with 23 point win over Collingwood
Peter Melesso – Round 22 v North Melbourne 1981 (14 Games South Melbourne, St Kilda & West Coast 1981-85 & 1989-90)
Melesso would only play one game for South Melbourne, which was the last ever game at Lake Oval. South Melbourne would lose to North Melbourne by 33 points.
Jack Hutchins – Round 5 v Port Adelaide 2011 (19 Games Gold Coast 2011-2014)
Hutchins would debut in Gold Coast first ever win a 3 point win against Port Adelaide.
Ray Hall – Round 22 v Carlton 1999 (99 Games Richmond 1999-2006)
Hall debuted in the last round of the season on Friday night when the scoreboard in the Ponsford Stand caught fire. The match was delayed by approx. 30 minutes and Richmond won by 11 points.
Jason Wild – Round 4 v Essendon 1995 (70 Games Collingwood 1995-99)
Wild would debut in the first Collingwood v Essendon Anzac Day match which resulted in a draw.
Ed Allan – Round 12 v Fremantle 2024 (2 Games Collingwood 2024-)
Allan would debut against the team his dad Ben captained and also briefly coached. The match had a controversial finish as Collingwood tied with Fremantle kicking a goal from a stoppage free kick when the Collingwood player did not pass the football straight back to the umpire. The other debutant for Collingwood this night was Will Parker (5 Games 2024-)
Rick Norman – Round 1 v Collingwood 1985 (13 Games North Melbourne & Brisbane 1985-87)
Norman debuted along with Stephen Hickey (37 Games 1985-88) and Collingwood’s Tony Burgess (21 Games 1985-86), Russell Dickson (1985-87), James Manson (167 games 1985-95) was the opening match of the year, the first ever night match at the MCG. The match was a Friday night in front of 65,628.
Glenn Bowyer – Round 22 v Sydney 1999 (55 Games Hawthorn & Carlton 1999-2005)
Bowyer’s debut was the last ever match at Waverley Park where 72,130 would see Hawthorn win by 85 points
Jeff Bruce – Round 9 v West Coast 1995 (7 Games Fitzroy 1995)
Jeff Bruce made his debut at Bruce Stadium in the only game ever to be played at Bruce Stadium in Canberra. The stadium was not named after the debutant Jeff Bruce.
Brett Chalmers – Round 4 v Geelong 1994 (75 Games Adelaide & Port Adelaide 1994-99)
Chalmers had the honour on debut of the opposition side giving him a guard of honour for his debut. In a strange tactic Malcolm Blight advised all the Geelong players to stand by the Adelaide race as they ran onto Football Park. It didn’t work as Adelaide won by 27 points.
Mark Foyster – Round 4 v Geelong 1983 (9 Games St. Kilda 1983-84)
Foyster was the lesser known debutant this day with 17-year-old from Ballarat Tony Lockett also making his debut kicking 2 goals in a 11 point loss. Lockett though was not the big story of the day with St Kilda unveiling Silvio Foschini and Paul Morwood from the Swans in their first game for the Saints on this day. Foschini had won a restraint of trade the previous day to play for St Kilda, but Morwood had not been cleared yet.
Jacob Heron – Round 9 v Port Adelaide 2018 (13 Games Gold Coast 2018-19)
Heron was the first player to debut at Jiangwan Stadium Shanghai where Port Adelaide won by 40 points.
Jay Neagle – Round 22 v West Coast 2007 (28 Games Essendon 2007-10)
Neagle would make his debut in Kevin Sheedy’s last game as Essendon coach in 8-point loss to West Coast in Perth.
Con Gorozidis – Round 8 v Geelong 1980 (34 Games St Kilda & Footscray 1980-83)
Geelong v St Kilda at Kardinia Park was the first ever match I went to. Dad milked cows 90 minutes west of Geelong and despite being a Collingwood supporter he still liked to go to a match at KP, which we could leave halfway through the last quarter and still milk the cows and I was happy to go. I have no memory of the match except I wore my Richmond jumper as I was going to the footy. Gorozidis and Sean Godsell (2 Games 1980-81) for St Kilda would debut in a match the Cats won by 63 points.
Nic Naitanui – Round 12 v Richmond 2009 (213 Games West Coast 2009-2022)
Naitanui’s debut was against Vickery in the ruck with Naitanui wearing the Number 9 jersey formerly worn by Ben Cousins who was playing the Eagles for the first time. Richmond would win by 15 points.
Justin Blumfield – Round 10 v St Kilda 1996 (148 Games Essendon & Richmond 1996-2004)
Blumfield’s debut was most unusual. When the Bombers ran out in on a Saturday night in June at Waverley, Blumfield was not part of the 21. That Saturday night the lights went out at Waverley with 28 minutes left in the match and Essendon 14 points up. The match would conclude the following Tuesday night with two 14-minute quarters and each team could bring in players. Essendon would bring in debutant Justin Blumfield as well as James Hird. Essendon would win by 22 points
Darren Collins – Round 7 v Fitzroy 1985 (49 Games Collingwood, Footscray & Fitzroy 1985-90)
Collins first match between Victoria Park new formerly co-tenants. They would be co-tenants for just two years before Fitzroy would move to Princess Park. Fitzroy would win this match by 79 points.
Peter Curtain – Round 22 v Fitzroy 1984 (2 Games St Kilda 1984-85)
Curtain debuedt in the last ever game at the Junction Oval. By 1984 St Kilda had moved to Moorabbin with Fitzroy now playing home games at the Junction Oval. There were 734 games at the Junction Oval and in this match, Fitzroy won by 57 points.
Jack Fitzpatrick – Round 24 v Port Adelaide 2011 (26 Games Melbourne & Hawthorn 2011-17)
Fitzpatrick played in the first match at the Adelaide Oval where Port Adelaide won by 8 points.
Michael Schulze – Round 12 v Hawthorn 1985 (91 Games Geelong 1985-91)
Schulze’s debut was at Princess Park which saw melees, several reports and Leigh Matthews break Neville Bruns jaw off the ball and Steve Hocking break Leigh Matthews nose in retaliation. Hawthorn would win by 29 points.
Clinton Wolf – Round 7 v West Coast 1995 (4 Games Fremantle 1995)
Wolf was the sole player to debut in the first ever Western Derby which saw West Coast win by 85 points.
Alastair Lord – Round 8 v Hawthorn 2022 (1 Game Essendon 2022)
The sub rule in 2022 was as an injury sub. In this match Essendon did not have an injury and Lord did not get on the ground. From what I can see Lord is the only player to be named sub in their only match and not got on the ground. Essendon would win by 27 points
Changkouth Jiath – Round 21 v GWS 2019 (56 Games Hawthorn 2019-)
Jiath would debut on a Friday night in Canberra where the temperature reached 2.7c and snow fell during the first half. This suited Hawthorn in their 56 point win.
Brodie Murdoch – Round 5 v Sydney 2013 (22 Games St Kilda 2013-16)
Murdoch and Josh Saunders (22 Games 2013-15) would debut on Anzac Day in the first AFL overseas premiership match for points at Wellington. Sydney would win by 16 points.
Dean Polo – Round 6 v Essendon 2006 (77 Games Richmond & St Kilda 2006-12)
Polo’s debut was the first Dreamtime at the MCG and Polo starred in Richmond’s 2 point win winning the inaugural Yiooken Award. Also, to debut was Jarrad Oakley-Nicholls (13 Games 2006-09)
Nick Trask – Round 10 v Sydney 1997 (12 Games Brisbane 1997-98)
Trask was the first player to debut for the newly merged club Brisbane Lions.
Others to debut
Paul Abbott – Roudn 13 v Melbourne 1984 (111 Games hawthorn & Fitzroy 1984-1993)
Abbott would debut in Leigh Matthews 300th game in a shock loss to Melbourne by 17 points.
Luke Ablett – Round 13 v Fremantle 2002 (133 Games Sydney 2002-09)
Ablett’s debut is also Paul Roos first game as interim coach (then appointed at the end of the year). Sydney would win by 77 points.
Matthew Ahmat – Round 21 v Essendon 1991 (8 Games Brisbane & Sydney 1991-94)
Ahmat along with Ian Kidgell (3 Games 1991) for Brisbane would debut in the last ever match at Windy Hill, a match Essendon won by 45 points.
Liam Anthony – Round 13 v Western Bulldogs 2009 (58 Games 2009-14)
Anthony debuted in interim coach Darren Crocker’s first game where Bulldogs won by 22 points.
Daniel Archer – Round 2 v Richmond 2011 (1 Game 2011)
Archer’s only game was a draw with Archer kicking a point late in the game to bring St Kilda within a point.
Paul Atkins – Round 23 v Brisbane 1992 (2 Games Sydney 1992)
Atkins and Robert Neill (44 Games Syd & St. K 1992-97) would debut in Brisbane Bears’ last ever home game at Carrara before moving permanently at the Gabba. Brisbane would win by 59 points.
Zac Bailey – Round 4 v Richmond 2018 (140 Games Brisbane 2018-)
Bailey’s first match was at the MCG where Brisbane scored their lowest ever score kicking 2.5.17 in a 93-point loss.
Drew Banfield – Round 16 v Essendon 1993 (265 Games West Coast 1993-2006)
Banfield first games saw the Eagles lose by 2 points and then famously Kevin Sheedy wave his Bomber jacket above his head, which then started a rivalry with the Eagles and jacket weaving done on both sides of the country.
Jimmy Bartel – Round 1 v Essendon 2002 (305 Games Geelong 2002-2016)
Bartel while a great of the AFL along with David Johnson (79 Games 2002-09) would debut with Gary Ablett junior in a 50-point loss
James Begley – Round 20 v North Melbourne 1999 (61 Games St. Kilda & Adelaide1999-2005)
Begley’s debut was at the Saints last match at Waverley Park where they lost by 25 points.
Rupert Betheras – Round 3 v West Coast 1999 (85 Games Collingwood 1999-2003)
Betheras is the last Collingwood player to debut at Victoria Park when the Pies went down by 36 points. Betheras also played in the last ever match in Round 22.
Brett Bewley – Round 10 v Brisbane 2019 (25 Games Fremantle 2019-21)
Bewley would debut in Lachie Neale’s first game against his old team, which saw Fremantle win by 1 point.
Mark Bickley – Round 4 v Essendon 1991 (272 Games Adelaide 1991-2003)
Bickley’s debut would be in Adelaide’s only trip to Windy Hill where the Bombers won by 45 points.
Nathan Blee – Round 20 v Hawthorn 2012 (6 Games Port Adelaide 2012-13)
Blee’s debut would be interim coach Garry Hocking’s first at Port Adelaide. Hawthorn would win by 72 points.
Blaine Boekhorst – Round 4 v St. Kilda 2015 (25 Games Carlton 2015-17)
Boekhorst along with teammate Matthew Dick (6 Games 2015), debuted in the last of 3 games to be held at Wellington. Carlton would win by 40 points.
Nathan Bower – Round 24 v Carlton 1991 (74 Games 1991-98)
Bower along with Ty Esler (12 Games 1991-93) debuted in the match David Cloke, in his farewell game, kicked 8 goals and received his third consecutive 3 vote Brownlow game at age 36.
Stuart Bown – Round 6 v Hawthorn 2001 (4 Games Adelaide 2001)
Bown debuted at the first ever match at York Park Launceston where Adelaide lost by 13 points.
Nathan Brown – Round 1 v Fremantle 1997 (219 Games Western Bulldogs & Richmond 1997-2009)
Brown would be the first player to debut as a Western Bulldog rather than Footscray player in a 4 point loss.
Andrew Browne – Round 1 v Carlton 2009 (12 Games Richmond 2009-11)
Browne’ debut would be along Ben Cousins’ debut for Richmond in a match the Blues won by 83 points.
Simon Buckley – Round 14 v Carlton 2007 (47 Games Melbourne & Collingwood 2007-12)
Buckley’s debut coincided with Mark Riley’s first game as interim coach in a 23 point win.
John Butcher – Round 21 v Hawthorn 2011 (31 Games Port Adelaide 2011-16)
Butcher, with Tom Jonas (216 Games 2011-23) debut was also Port Adelaide’s biggest ever loss, losing by 165 points.
Jye Caldwell – Round 21 v Hawthorn 2019 (78 Games GWS & Essendon 2019-)
Caldwell would debut on a Friday night in Canberra where the temperature reached 2.7c and snow fell during the first half. This suited Hawthorn in their 56 point win.
David Cameron Round 5 v North Melbourne 1986 (56 Games Geelong & Brisbane 1986-91)
In 1986 the VFL had a double header at the MCG. The first match Melbourne v Sydney at 2:10pm followed by Geelong v North Melbourne at 5pm. Cameron was the only debutant on the day where North won by 62 points.
Tom Carr – Round 4 v Adelaide 1997 (5 Games Port Adelaide 1997-99)
Carr along with Stephen Daniels (58 Games 1997-2000) would debut in the first ever Showdown which Port won by 11 points.
Ross Christensen – Round 12 v Collingwood 1982 (12 Games Footscray & Geelong 1982-83)
Christensen’s first game was also Footscray new coach Ian Hampshire’s first game, while it was Collingwood interim coach Tom Hafey 2nd game. Collingwood would win by 66 points.
Xavier Clarke – Round 3 v Port Adelaide 2002 (106 Games St Kilda & Brisbane 2002-10)
Clarke would debut on the same day as Shaun Burgoyne. Burgoyne would play 407 games until 2021 and would play in an 83-point win over the Saints.
Mitch Clisby – Round 13 v St Kilda 2013 (8 Games Melbourne 2013)
Clisby would debut in Neil Craig’s first game as interim coach of Melbourne.
Jason Cloke – Round 2 v West Coast 2002 (76 Games Collingwood 2002-06)
Cloke’s opposition debutant would be Chris Judd who starred in a 1 point win to Collingwood.
Josh Cowan – Round 10 v Gold Coast 2011 (16 Games Geelong 2011-17)
Cowan debuted in the match Gary Ablett played against Geelong for the first time. Geelong won by 66 points.
Harry Cunningham – Round 1 v GWS 2012 (208 Games Sydney 2012-)
This match was first battle of the bridge where Sydney won by 63 points. The Giants had 17 debutants for this match.
Chris Daniher – Round 17 v Sydney 1987 (124 Games Essendon 1987-97)
This match would see Essendon suffer their biggest loss ever losing by 163 points.
Cameron Delaney – Round 2 v GWS 2012 (6 Games North Melbourne 2012-13)
Delaney would debut in North Melbourne’s first home game at Bellerive Oval where North won by 129 points.
Scott Direen – Round 9 v Geelong 1993 (52 Games Sydney 1993-97)
Direen’s first game came on the day Richard Osborne had a sickening head clash with Dale Lewis and left the ground in an ambulance. Geelong won by 25 points.
Hugh Dixon – Round 23 v Port Adelaide 2019 (11 Games Fremantle & West Coast 2019-22)
Dixon only played one game for Fremantle which was also David Hale’s only game as coach following Ross Lyon’s resignation. Port Adelaide won by 43 points.
Nathan Drummond – Round 5 v Melbourne 2015 (5 Games Richmond 2015-16)
Drummond’s first game was the first Anzac Eve Night match between Richmond v Melbourne. Melbourne won by 32 points and sadly Drummond did his ACL.
Michael Dunstan – Round 1 v Carlton 1993 (43 Games Fitzroy & West Coast 1993-95)
Dunstan kicked the winning goal with seconds to play to give Fitzroy a six point win.
Ricky Dyson – Round 3 v West Coast 2004 (114 Games Essendon 2004-2012)
Dyson’s debut was the match where James Hird kicked the winning goal in a 6 point win and hugged an Essendon fan after Hird had a controversial week after criticism of umpire Scott McLaren.
Jake Edwards – Round 1v Richmond 2008 (5 Games Carlton 2008)
Edwards’ debut game was Chris Judd’s first game for Carlton in a 30 point loss.
David Ellard – Round 7 v West Coast 2008 (63 Games Carlton 2008-15)
Ellard’s first game was Chris Judd’s first game against West Coast. The match was at Subiaco and Carlton won by 37 points.
Robert Elphinstone – Round 2 v Hawthorn 1980 (157 Games St Kilda 1980-89)
Elphinstone’s debut was Mike Patterson’s last game as St Kilda coach with the Saints going down by 33 points. Alex Jesaulenko would coach the following week.
Matthew Fergusson – Round 12 v Port Adelaide 2003 (12 Games St Kilda 2003-08)
Fergusson was the first Saint to debut at Launceston for St Kilda where Port Adelaide won by 42 points.
Sam Flanders – Round 11 v Essendon 2020 (66 Games Gold Coast 2020-)
Flanders’ debut was in Gold Coast’s first ever draw.
Dustin Fletcher – Round 2 v Carlton 1993 (400 Games Essendon 1993-2015)
Fletcher’s debut was a famous draw where Stephen Kernahan had a shot at goal approx. 45 metres on an angle after the siren and kicked it on the full.
Jake Florenca – Round 8 v Brisbane 2022 (1 Game West Coast 2022)
Florenca sole game was under Matthew Knights as coach as Adam Simpson was unable due to Covid. Brisbane won by 75 points.
Nathan Foley – Round 10 v Melbourne 2005 (154 Games Richmond 2005-14)
Foley would debut in the match Nathan Brown suffered a horrible broken leg. Melbourne won by 57 points.
Cruize Garlett – Round 12 v Adelaide 2009 (32 Games North Melbourne 2009-2012)
Garlett debuted in Dean Laidley’s last game as coach which North Melbourne lost by 44 points.
Darren Glass – Round 4 v Adelaide 2000 (270 Games West Coast 2000-2014)
Glass would debut at the WACA in a match Scott Cummings kicked the biggest haul of goals with 14 at the WACA in a 114 point win for the Eagles.
Adrian Gleeson – Round 7 v Collingwood 1986 (176 Games Carlton 1986-1996)
Gleeson’s debut was a rare appearance in the 1980’s by Carlton at Victoria Park which won by 40 points.
Jack Graham – Round 22 v Fremantle 2017 (131 Games Richmond 2017-24)
Graham debuted in Fremantle’s last match at Subiaco in a match Richmond won by 104 points.
Rod Grinter – Round 2 v Hawthorn 1985 (134 Games Melbourne 1985-94)
Grinter’s debut was in the same match as Jason Dunstall debuted for Hawthorn in a 68 point win for Hawthorn.
David Hale – Round 5 v Carlton 2003 (237 Games North Melbourn & Hawthorn 2003-15)
Hale’s debut was the first time Carlton coach Denis Pagan would coach against North Melbourne which Carlton won by 9 points.
Josh Hall – Round 16 v Richmond 2012 (7 Games Gold Coast 2012-15)
Hall debuted in the match Karmichael Hunt kicked after the siren to give the Gold Coast a 2 point win.
Shaun Hart – Round 1 v Richmond 1990 (273 Games Brisbane 1990-2004)
Hart along with Brad Rowe (73 Games 1990-96) and Richmond’s Sean Bowden (6 Games 1990-91), Brendon Gale (244 Games 1990-2021), Chris Naish (161 Games 1990-99) and Stephen Ryan (51 Games 1990-94) all played in the first Saturday night match which Brisbane won by 59 points.
Ben Haynes – Round 19 v Fremantle 2000 (26 Games Richmond & Essendon 2000-05)
Haynes debuted in the last of 72 matches to be played at the WACA with Richmond winning by 27 points.
Ollie Hollands – Round 1 v Richmond 2023 (42 Games Carlton 2023-)
Hollands debuted with Lachlan Cowan (24 Games 2023-) in the first match of the 2023 Season which was a draw.
John Holt – Round 17 v Footscray 1981 (71 Games North Melbourne 1981-88)
Holt, along with Peter Smith (40 Games 1981-87) debut, was Barry Cable’s first game as coach of North Melbourne who would win by 9 points.
Josh Honey – Round 12 v Fremantle 2020 (17 Games Carlton 2020-23)
Honey’s debut was the match that Jack Newnes kicked a goal from outside 50 on the boundary after the siren to win by 4 points.
Allen Jakovich – Round 1 v West Coast 1991 (54 Games Melbourne & Footscray 1991-96)
Jakovich along with David Schwarz (173 Games 1991-2002) debuted in the lowest score ever at Subiaco with Melbourne kicking 2.8 and losing by 79 points.
Tew Jiath – Round 15 v North Melbourne 2024 (1 Game Collingwood 2024-)
Jiath’s debut was the match Collingwood came from 54 points down in the third quarter to win by 6 points.
Brad Johnson – Round 18 v Collingwood 1994 (364 Games Western Bulldogs 1994-2010)
Johnson debuted in the match Tony Shaw broke the record for most games for Collingwood passing Gordon Coventry’s 306 games. Bulldogs would win by 32 points.
Chris Johnson – Round 2 v Essendon 1994 (264 Games Fitzroy & Brisbane 1994-2007)
Johnson with John Barker (168 Games 1994-2006) and Jarrod Molloy (169 Games 1994-2003) debuted in Tim Watson 300th game which Fitzroy won by 13 points.
Riley Knight – Round 15 v West Coast 2015 (55 Games Adelaide 2015-20)
Knighst’s debut was Scott Camporeale’s first game as interim coach which the Eagles won by 56 points.
Brian Lake – Round 21 v Carlton 2002 (251 Games Western Bulldogs and Hawthorn 2002-15)
Lake would debut in Terry Wallace’s last game as coach which Carlton won by 4 points.
Doulton Langlands – Round 18 v Western Bulldogs 2019 (3 Games St Kilda 2019)
Langlands’ debut was Brett Ratten’s first as St Kilda coach in which Saints won by 27 points.
Patrick Lipinski – Round 23 v Hawthorn 2017 (118 Games Western Bulldogs & Collingwood 2017-)
Lipinski’s debut would be in Robert Murphy’s last game as a Bulldogs player while Harry Morrison (103 Games 2017-) debut in the same game which was Luke Hodge’s last as a Hawk. Hawthorn would win by 9 points.
Jack Lucas – Round 13 v St Kilda 1982 (19 Games Sydney 1982-84)
Lucas was the first Swan to debut at the SCG in a 96-point win over St Kilda
Scott Lucas – Round 5 v Collingwood 1996 (270 Games 1996-2009)
Lucas was the first Essendon player to debut on Anzac Day in the second annual match between the two teams in a 12 point win for Collingwood.
Tom Lynch – Round 7 v Brisbane 2011 (220 Games Gold Coast & Richmond 2011-)
Lynch along with Sam Day (155 Games 2011-), Joseph Daye (4 Games 2011) and Brisbane Bryce Retzlaff (11 Games 2011) all debuted in the first ever Q clash which the Suns won by 8 points.
Brent MacAffer – Round 5 v Essendon 2009 (77 Games Collingwood 2009-16)
MacAffer’s Anzac Day debut was the famous match where David Zaharakis kicked a goal at the end to win by 5 points after being 14 points behind 5 minutes earlier.
Troy Makepeace – Round 4 v Geelong 2000 (139 Games North Melbourne 2000-06
Makepeace’s debut was in North Melbourne first ever home game at Docklands with North winning by 5 points.
Adam Marcon – Round 19 v GWS 2016 (2 Games Richmond 2016
Marcon’s debut was the match the lowest score conceded at Canberra with Richmond kicking 3.5 and losing by 88 points.
Todd Marshall- Round 22 v Western Bulldogs 2017 (116 Games Port Adelaide 2017-)
Marshall’s debut was the first game ever at Ballarat with Port Adelaide winning by 17 points.
Greg McAdam – Round 1 v Sydney 1985 (10 Games St Kilda 1985)
McAdam with Frank Carbone (10 Games 1985-87), Robert Keeble (2 Games 1985) and Sydney’s Jamie Duursma (59 Games 1985-89), John Ironmonger (88 Games 1985-91), Darren McAsey (34 Games 1985-91) and Mark Russell (14 Games 1985) debuted in the biggest winning margin at Moorabbin with Sydney winning by 110 points.
Todd McHardy – Round 7 v Sydney 1996 (5 Games 1996-97)
McHardy would debut in 1996 in the 100th year celebration of the VFL/AFL.
Adam McPhee – Round 7 v Sydney 2001 (223 Games Fremantle & Essendon 2001-12)
McPhee’s debut would be Damian Drum’s last game as coach before he was sacked mid year. Sydney won by 19 points.
James Meiklejohn – Round 5 v Melbourne 2003 (6 Games Sydney 2003-04)
Meiklejohn’s debut was in the first night match played on Anzac Day. Sydney won by 24 points.
Zach Merrett – Round 1 v North Melbourne 2014 (229 Games Essendon 2014-)
Merrett, with Patrick Ambrose (88 Games 2014-21), and Martin Gleeson (97 Games 2014-21) would debut in Dustin Fletcher’s record breaking 379th game for Essendon. Essendon won by 39 points.
Harry Miller – Round 1 v Sydney 2005 (18 Games Hawthorn 2005-06)
Miller with Josh Thurgood (13 Games 2005-07) would debut in the same game as Lance Franklin would in a 63 point win by Sydney.
Michael Mitchell – Round 1 v West Coast 1987 (81 Games Richmond 1987-91)
Mitchell and fellow West Australian Peter Wilson (171 Games 1987-95) would debut in West Coast’s first ever game with the Eagles winning by 14 points.
Irving Mosquito – Round 13 v Richmond 2020 (4 Games Essendon 2020)
Mosquito’s debut was the Dreamtime game that was held in Darwin with Richmond winning by 12 points.
Kane Munro – Round 21 v Fremantle 2000 (18 Games West Coast 2000-03)
Munro’s debut was in the famous Derby match that had several brawls. Fremantle won by 1 point.
Brad Murphy – Round 20 v Port Adelaide 2004 (7 Games Western Bulldogs 2004-05)
Murphy’s debut was in the first match held at Marrara Oval Darwin, where Port won by 86 points.
Darren Murphy – Round 2 v Essendon 1985 (4 Games Fitzroy 1985)
Murphy along with Paul Tilley (15 Games 1985-87) debut was in Fitzroy’s first home at Victoria Park where Essendon would win by 103 points
David Murphy – Round 14 v Collingwood 1984 (156 Games Sydney 1984-93)
Murphy’s debut would be the game Tony Franklin would coach the Swans in his only match due to illness to Ricky Quade. Collingwood won by 31 points.
Ben Nason – Round 1 v Carlton 2010 (23 Games Richmond 2010-11)
Nason along with Relton Roberts (2 Games 2010) would debut alongside Dustin Martin in a 56 point win by Carlton.
Michael Newton – Round 13 v Essendon 2007 (28 Games Melbourne 2007-11)
Newton’s debut would be Neale Daniher’s last as coach as Essendon would win by 2 points.
Reilly O’Brien – Round 20 v Brisbane 2016 (121 Games Adelaide 2016-)
In O’Brien’s debut match Adelaide kicked 27.15.177 the highest score at the Adelaide Oval as Adelaide won by 138 points.
Shane Parker – Round 3 v Fitzroy 1995 (238 Games Fremantle 1995-2007)
Parker along with Jeff White (268 Games 1995-2008) would debut in Fremantle first ever win by 43 points.
Jack Petruccelle – Round 6 v Fremantle 2018 (88 Games West Coast 2018-)
Petruccelle’s debut would be in the first Derby game held at the Perth Stadium where West Coast would win by 8 points.
Andrew Phillips – Round 7 v Gold Coast 2012 (82 Games GWS, Carlton & Essendon 2012-23)
Phillips’ debut match would be GWS’ first ever win, beating Gold Coast by 27 points.
Michael Prior – Round 20 v Collingwood 1994 (90 Games Essendon & West Coast 1994-2002)
Prior’s debut was strange before the ball was bounced. As Collingwood ran through the banner Essendon was on the side and this sight would start an all-in brawl of all 42 players. Collingwood would win by 28 points.
Joel Reynolds- Round 3 v Brisbane 2002 (38 Games Essendon 2002-06)
Reynolds’ debut would be Kevin Sheedy 500th Game as coach with Brisbane winning by 50 points.
Nick Riewoldt – Round 15 v Adelaide 2000 (336 Games St Kilda 2000-17)
Riewoldt with Chris Oliver (10 Games 2001-03) debuted in Malcolm Blight’s last ever as coach, with Adelaide winning by 97 points.
Jon Riggs – Round 18 v Footscray 1984 (6 Games St Kilda 1984-85)
Riggs’ debut was Tony Jewell’s last as St Kilda coach with Footscray winning by 33 points.
Aiden Riley – Round 19 v Port Adelaide 2011 (25 Games Adelaide & Melbourne 2011-15)
Riley’s debut was interim coach Mark Bickley’s first as coach with Adelaide winning by 32 games.
Willie Rioli – Round 2 v Western Bulldogs 2018 (90 Games WCE & Port Adelaide 2018-)
Rioli would debut with Jaymie Graham debut as interim coach due to Adam Simpson unavailability. West Coast would win by 51 points.
Michael Rischitelli – Round 17 v Adelaide 2004 (243 Games Brisbane & Gold Coast 2004-19)
In Rischitelli’s debut game Brisbane would get their highest score 29.15.189 and record their biggest win with 141 points.
Sam Rowe – Round 2 v Collingwood 2013 (100 Games Carlton & St Kilda 2013-19)
Rowe debut was the first time Mick Malthouse would coach against Collingwood, with Collingwood winning by 17 points.
Tim Ruffles – Round 15 v Adelaide 2009 (5 Games Fremantle 2009-10)
In Ruffles’ debut game Fremantle scored their lowest ever score of 1.7.13 losing by 117 points.
Liam Ryan – Round 1 v Sydney 2018 (105 Games West Coast 2018-)
Ryan along with Daniel Venables (21 games 2018-19) and Jake Waterman (104 Games 2018-) would debut in the first game at Perth Stadium.
Laurence Schache – Round 4 v Geelong 1990 (29 Games Brisbane 1990-91)
Schache’s first game was Brisbane’s first at the Gabba with Geelong winning by 102 points.
Tim Scott – Round 4 v Fitzroy 1995 (1 Game Sydney 1995)
Scott’s first game was the first time Paul Roos playing against Fitzroy. Sydney would win by 32 points.
Angus Sheldrick – Round 1 v GWS 2022 (9 Games Sydney 2022-)
Sheldrick’s debut would be the last of 55 games played at Stadium Australia with Sydney winning by 20 points.
Greg Stafford – Round 4 v Essendon 1993 (204 Games Sydney & Richmond 1993-2006)
Stafford’s debut would be coach Gary Buckenara’s last as Sydney coach as Essendon won by 86 points.
James Stewart – Round 23 v Gold Coast 2013 (78 Games GWS & Essendon 2013-22)
Stewart’s debut game would be Kevin Sheedy’s last ever as coach as Gold Coast won by 83 points.
Timothy Sumner – Round 10 v Geelong 2013 (17 Games Gold Coast 2013-14)
Sumner’s debut was in the first ever match held under lights at Kardinia Park which Geelong won by 52 points.
Keith Thomas – Round 4 v Brisbane 1987 (28 Games Fitzroy 1987-88)
Thomas along with teammate Mark Trewella (27 Games 1987-91) debuted in the first ever match played at Carrara.
Wayne Thornborrow – Round 7 v Sydney 1994 (13 Games St Kilda 1994-95)
Thornborrow debuted in the same match Tony Lockett kicked 11 for the Saints and cleaned up Peter Caven as the Saints won by 1 point.
Warren Tredrea – Round 2 v Essendon 1997 (255 Games 1997-2010)
Tredrea along with Nigel Fiegert (19 Games 1997-99) and Bowen Lockwood (50 Games 1997-2001) would debut at Port Adelaide’s first home game.
Adam Treloar – Round 3 v West Coast 2012 (254 Games GWS, Collingwood and Western Bulldogs 2012-)
Treloar’s debut was the only match ever played at Blacktown with Eagles win by 81 points.
Jason Tutt – Round 22 v Port Adelaide 2011 (40 Games Western Bulldogs and Carlton 2011-16)
Tutt and Ayce Cordy (27 Games 2011-15) debuted in interim coach Paul Williams’ first came as coach.
Tyrone Vickery – Round 12 v West Coast 2009 (125 Games Richmond & Hawthorn 2009-17)
Vickery’s first game was Jade Rawlings first as interim coach of Richmond and was also the first game of Ben Cousins against his old team.
Dante Viseniti – Round 16 v Essendon 2023 (6 Games Port Adelaide 2023-)
In Viseniti first game Daniel Houston kicked a goal from outside 50 after the siren to give Port Adelaide a 4 point win.
Marty Warry – Round 19 v Sydney 1995 (6 Games Fitzroy 1995-96)
Warry’s debut was Bernie Quinlan’s last as coach with Sydney helped by Tony Lockett’s 16 goals winning by 126 points.
Fergus Watts – Round 13 v Western Bulldogs 2004 (6 Games Adelaide and St Kilda 2004-06)
Watts’ debut was Gary Ayres last as coach with the Crows winning by 32 points
Jacob Wehr – Round 10 v West Coast 2022 (25 Games GWS 2022-)
Wehr’s debut was Mark McVeigh’s first as interim coach of GWS with the Giants winning by 52 points.
Simon Wiggins – Round 5 v St Kilda 2001 (116 Games Carlton 2001-09)
Wiggins and Jordan Doering (18 Games 2001-02) debuted against St Kilda who had unveiled recruit Aaron Hamill which bought out heated emotions from the Carlton faithful. Carlton would win by 33 points.
Alex Woodward – Round 18 v Sydney 2014 (2 Games Hawthorn 2014)
Woodward first game would be Buddy Franklin’s first game against Hawthorn at the MCG with Hawthorn winning by 10 points.
More from Rodney can be read Here
To return to the www.footyalmanac.com.au home page click HERE
Our writers are independent contributors. The opinions expressed in their articles are their own. They are not the views, nor do they reflect the views, of Malarkey Publications.
Do you enjoy the Almanac concept?
And want to ensure it continues in its current form, and better? To help keep things ticking over please consider making your own contribution.
Become an Almanac (annual) member – CLICK HERE

Brett Bowey debuted for St Kilda in 1988, in the same match as Robert Harvey made his debut for St Kilda. Bowey, a rover, kicked 2 goals on his debut and he played 85 games and kicked 79 goals for St Kilda from 1988-94.
Brett Bowey’s son, Jack Bowey, is a premiership player for Melbourne. Brett Bowen’s sister, Belinda Bowey, was the first player to play 300 games in the Victorian Women’s Football League (VFLW).
Of course, Robert Harvey ended up playing 383 games and kicked 215 goals for St Kilda from 1988-2008 and won 2 Brownlow Medals among his many achievements.
Firstly, I forgot to mention that Bowey and Harvey’s debut was against Footscray at the Western Oval and Footscray won by 69 points.
Ryan Fitzgerald, a tall forward, made his debut for the Sydney Swans against St Kilda in Round 1, 2000 at Colonial Stadium. This was St Kilda’s first ever match at the Docklands. Sydney won by 34 points.
Fitzgerald kicked 5 goals on his debut and “looked set for a big career.” Injuries derailed his career and he ended up playing 18 games and kicking 23 goals for Sydney and Adelaide.
He went on to become a radio personality, television presenter and comedian.
Kudos for the remarkable research effort here Rodney.
Mark Foyster was (still is?) a teacher at Haileybury, a very genial bloke who took on the coaching of the Girls’ Thirds softball team with great humour – I wish I’d known about the circumstances of his debut at the time.
Tony Lockett debuted for St Kilda in Round 4 in 1983 against Geelong at VFL Park.
There was a high degree of controversy surrounding this game since St Kilda, after seeking legal advice, decided to include Sydney’s Paul Morwood in their line-up without a clearance from the Swans or a permit from the League.
According to the rules at the time, if St Kilda had won, they would have risked forfeiting the premiership points. As it turned out, they went down in a spirited effort to Geelong by 11 points.
Lockett ended up playing a total of 281 games for St Kilda and Sydney and kicked a record 1360 goals, as well as a Brownlow Medal, among his many achievements.
Firstly, apologies for mentioning Tony Lockett’s debut and Paul Morwood playing without a clearance as well as Silvio Foschini, as it’s just come to my attention that it was already mentioned under Mark Foyster’s debut for St Kilda the same day.
James Gwilt made his debut for St Kilda in the final round of the 2005 AFL season against the Brisbane Lions at Telstra Dome, in a match where St Kilda won by a club-record 139 points and small forward Stephen Milne kicked 11 goals for the Saints. At debut, Gwilt was only one of two AFL players (the other being Mal Michael) to have a Papua New Guinean parent.
G’day Rodney, I’ll go back to a couple of interesting debutants from the opening round of 1971. They weren’t the only debutants of note that day, but their debuts coincided with different happenings/milestones. It was a very hot sunny day to start a new season.
https://www.footyalmanac.com.au/almanac-footy-history-round-1-1971/
David Clarke turned out for Geelong at home against St Kilda. Geelong started well before St. Kilda ‘turned it on’, winning by 94 points their biggest win at Geelong. In the three decades I followed Geelong I don’t recall a home ground trouncing by a bigger margin.
Clarke proved a wonderful player for Geelong winning the Best & Fairest in 1971, 1978 & 1979. He played 14 times for Victoria; also All- Australian in 1972. He played 211 games, kicking 319 goals in his VFL career, that finished with him playing at Carlton. There was of course the post career Pyramid financial scandal that saw him receive a fine, and suspended sentence, certainly different happenings.
Another Debutant that day was John Gallus, a ruck/forward for Melbourne. He’d played VFL reserves for Melbourne in the mid 1960’s, then went to Waverley in the VFA. Following that he returned to Gippsland, finally making his VFL debut aged 25. He kicked 3 goals that day as Melbourne inflicted a huge loss on South Melbourne coached by former Melbourne legend Norm Smith. Gallus had a short career, of 28 games, 39 goals, prior to returning to Gippsland after the 1972 season. He spent a few more years playing good football for teams to the east of Melbourne.
One other debutant from that year I’ll mention is Trevor Heath who wore 58 for Essendon. His debut,sole game, saw the Bombers take on Collingwood at Victoria Park. Collingwood led by Peter McKenna booting 12 goals, big ruckman Graeme Jenkin with 40 hitouts, and the reliable pairing of Des Tuddenham, and Wayne Richardson, both who got 40 + possessions, with 7 goals between them. won easily. Their victory scoreline of 30-20-200 to 7-11-53, 147 points remains Collingwoods biggest win over Essendon. It was also their highest score, biggest winning margin, until their 1979 victory over St. Kilda.
Glen!
Whilst I’m on a roll I’ll move back to 1970.
Alan Thompson debuted for Fitzroy in the opening round. The speedy wingman played 138 games, kicking 59 goals for Fitzroy from 1970 up until 1979. His debut was certainly in line with a different happening.
Not just did Fitzroy beat reigning premiers Richmond 16-20-116 to 14-12-96 it was on a Sunday; April 5 1970, the first time a VFL match was played on a Sunday. It’s worth noting that due to special guests attending, the second half was televised live. The special guests: the British royal family, happily watching their loyal subjects play football in their presence.
Alan Thompson, Fitzroy, opened the 1970 season with a range of firsts. They also took part in the first match at VFL Park, Waverley, losing to Geelong 17-12-114 to 7-11-53. This was in round three. Debuting for Geelong was Jimmy Wright who kicked 2 of his 5 career goals that day. Wright was a redhead recruited from North Hobart, who also wore contact lens. From 1970, until the end of 1972, he played 20 games, kicking 5 goals for Geelong. I recall a clash at Windy Hill in 1972 when he was apparently involved in an incident.
Glen!
This is nostalgia for success starved St Kilda fans:
In round 6 of 1965, Julian White made his debut for St Kilda, on the same day that Barry Breen and Kevin ‘Cowboy’ Neale made their debuts for St Kilda against North Melbourne at the Coburg ground (North Melbourne played their home games at Coburg for one year after a dispute with Melbourne Council had caused them to vacate Arden Street).
St Kilda won that match against North Melbourne by 38 points and Breen kicked a goal.
White only played 3 games for St Kilda and kicked 1 goal. Barry Breen (300 games/308 goals) kicked the winning point for St Kilda in the dying minutes of the 1966 Grand Final and Kevin Neale (256 games/301 goals) kicked 5 goals for St Kilda that day, for their 1st ever premiership!
Charlie Hardy made his senior VFL debut for Essendon, aged 34 years and 100 days (a current league record) in Round 10, of 2021. At just 157cm and 54kg, Hardy is one of the smallest players to ever play at a top level.
He had previously played 224 games for North Melbourne in the VFA from 1908-1921, and was a brilliant rover helping North Melbourne to premierships in 1910, 1914, 1915 and 1918). He was also a member of the famous “invincibles” side that went undefeated in a record 58 games. He captained North Melbourne in 1914.
Hardy left the club along with many teammates upon the temporary disbanding of North Melbourne in 1921, and joined Essendon in the VFL.
He continued to be a leading player for Essendon, playing in Essendon’s 1923 and 1924 premiership teams and ended up playing 36 games and kicking 21 goals. When he retired in 1925 aged 38, he was the oldest player to play a League match for Essendon; this record was overtaken by Dustin Fletcher, who played his final game for Essendon in 2015, aged 40 years and 21 days.
He also represented Victoria in 1921, at the Perth Carnival.
Hardy later coached Essendon from 1928-30 and St Kilda from 1931-32.
Claude Clough made his debut for St Kilda in 1900, as the youngest player to ever play league football, aged 15 years, 209 days.
Until March 2012, the record was thought to be held by Keith Bromage, who made his debut at at 15 years and 287 days. Research by the official AFL historians discovered that Clough was born in 1884, not the previously thought 1880.
Clough’s first game of league football was notable, as the result of the match was overturned almost a week after the game concluded. The match finished as a draw, with both teams having scored 68 points, but a point kicked by Melbourne at the end of the third quarter was later disallowed and St Kilda was awarded the win. (It would take over 106 years before another game’s result would be later overturned-coincidentally involving St Kilda-in the infamous Surengate match.) The 1900 victory with Clough also marked St Kilda’s first win since they entered the league in 1897, and it was their only win for the season.
Clough ended up playing 23 games and kicking 8 goals for St Kilda from 1900-1901.
Apologies for the typing error in my 2nd last comment.
I meant to type that Charlie Hardy made his debut for Essendon, aged 34 years and 100 days (a current league record) in Round 10, of 1921, not 2021.
Charlie Hardy kicked 2 goals for Essendon on his debut, when they beat Melbourne by 26 points.
Also, when Claude Clough made his debut for St Kilda in 1900, as the youngest player, aged 15 years and 209 days, it was Round 1 of 1900, when St Kilda beat Melbourne by 1 point at the Junction Oval. Melbourne went on to win the 1900 premiership.
Unfortunately for St Kilda, Glen brought up at the end of his first comment, that Collingwood’s biggest winning margin was against St Kilda by 178 points at Victoria Park in Round 4, 1979 and they kicked their highest score of 207 points that day. At the time, that was the greatest winning margin in VFL/AFL history.
Peter Daicos made his debut in that match.
Later in Round 17, 1979, Fitzroy beat Melbourne by the current greatest winning margin of 190 points at Waverley. Fitzroy also kicked the highest VFL/AFL score of 238 points. It was later broken by Geelong who kicked 239 points, when they beat Brisbane by 164 points at Metricon Stadium in Round 7, 1992. Geelong later kicked 233 points to beat Melbourne in Round 19, 2011, at Kardinia Park, by 186 points, their greatest winning margin.
Unfortunately again for St Kilda, Collingwood again kicked their highest score again of 211 points in Round 17, 1980 at Waverley.
In better news for St Kilda, Max King made his debut for St Kilda in Round 1, 2020, against North Melbourne at Marvel Stadium. St Kilda won the match by 4 points. What is significant about this was that four days later, the season was suspended due to the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic. The season resumed on 11 June and ran until 24 October. A shortened season was played, comprising a 17-game home-and-away-season followed by a finals series featuring the top eight clubs; all matches were shortened to 80% of their usual length. The premiership was won by Richmond for the 13th time and second time consecutively, after it defeated Geelong by 31 points in the 2020:AFL Grand Final.
Dean Greig made his debut for St Kilda in Round 21, 1991, against Carlton at Waverley. He compiled 39 disposals on his debut, which included 23 kicks and 16 handballs, the VFL/AFL record for most ever disposals on debut. Tony Lockett kicked 13 goals for St Kilda in that match, which was the most number of goals at the time kicked by any St Kilda player. St Kilda’s score of 155 points and a 54 point winning margin were its highest recorded against Carlton at the time.
Dean Greig ended up playing 33 games and kicked 8 goals for St Kilda from 1991-94.
In Round 6 of 1978, David Code made his debut for Melbourne against St Kilda at the MCG.
The match was notable for St Kilda kicking their own record score of 204 points and Melbourne kicked 141 points. St Kilda won by 63 points. At the time, this was the highest aggregate score (345 points) for a match, beating the previous highest aggregate score of the 1972 VFL Grand Final.
It was also the highest score that Melbourne had ever conceded, at the time.
George Young kicked 7 goals for St Kilda and Russell Greene kicked 5 goals for St Kilda in that match.
David Code ended up playing a total of 6 games for Melbourne in 1978 and he kicked one goal.
In Round 18 of 1993, Leigh Capsalis made his debut for St Kilda against Sydney at the SCG. During this game, a pig with a number 4 written on it and the name ‘Pluga’ (misspelt) also written on it, ran onto the ground during play, from a diehard Swans supporter, Joe, the pig farmer. It was meant to put Tony Lockett off, who was playing for St Kilda back then. However, Lockett wasn’t playing that day. Darren Holmes from the Sydney Swans, ended up tackling the pig. St Kilda brought home the bacon, winning by 37 points.
That was the only game that Leigh Capsalis played in his AFL career and I guess it’s something he can tell his grandchildren about!
Brilliantly researched and a very entertaining read Rod!!
To pick out just one, I was at the Collingwood v Fremantle game at Victoria Park in 1995, one of Clinton Wolf’s 4 games. It seemed like he was a big cult figure that day and that year, feels like he played 40 games!
Brendan Burnett made his debut for North Melbourne against Collingwood in Round 5 of 1978, at Arden Street, North Melbourne. On this day an elephant was unleashed on the ground.
One of North Melbourne’s pennant members, named Jack Allan, was a bit of a character and he owned Allan Amusements. To promote his circus, it was decided that an elephant will be brought onto the ground. After the curtain raiser concluded, the elephant was unleashed literally. The handler was with him, and there was a member of the cheer squad riding the elephant. They were walking around the old Gasometer Wing.
The sight of an elephant on the turf took everyone by surprise. There was a roar from the crowd when the Collingwood team came onto the ground. The noise was too much for the elephant and it started to panic, threatening to cut loose. Thankfully, the elephant calmed down and it’s handler was able to wrest back control of it. The young rider was unscathed.
For the record, North Melbourne came from behind at the last break to defeat Collingwood by 9 points, which was no easy tusk!
Brendan Burnett ended up playing a total of 6 games for North Melbourne in 1978.
April 3 1982 was the first time I voted. I was one of those who voted the ALP into power, their first time heading the Victorian government since 1955. If the memory is working, six players debuted that day, including a very notable pair.
Maurice Rioli debuted for Richmond against Fitzroy. He went on to play 118 games, kicking 80 goals in his time at Tigerland. Maurice returned to the Northern Territory where he played further football, prior to a period as an elected ALP member of the Northern Territory parliament. Sadly Maurice is no longer with us, though the Rioli name continued appearing at the AFL level.
On the same day the best player I’ve ever seen debuted. GOD, aka, Gary Ablett. This was for Hawthorn against Geelong. Ablett kicked a goal on his debut, one of the 10 he kicked in his 6 games with Hawthorn. We know he ‘went bush’ in 1983, returned to play with Geelong in 1984: the rest is history.
Oh yes, both of these wonderful players debuted in winning sides.
Glen!
Brilliant work again, Rodney. As usual your great work has got me googling, pondering, reminiscing about players of days gone by.
In Round 1 of 1986, four Carlton players debuted together, namely Craig Bradley, Jon Dorotich, Mil Hanna and Stephen Kernahan against Hawthorn at Waverley. Hawthorn won by 36 points.
Kernahan kicked 2 goals and Dorotich was named in the best players in that game. Mil Hanna injured his knee in the opening minute in his debut match and was out for the whole season.
What’s notable about this match was that Craig Bradley is the last known player to combine both first class cricket and AFL Football at the same time. Alex Carey later captained a GWS team, but that was before GWS entered the AFL. Carey then went to concentrate on cricket only. Alex Keith later only went to AFL football full time, once his first class cricket contract wasn’t renewed.
The debuts were also notable because with 4 great players debuting, and then another great player in Peter Motley who debuted for Carlton in Round 2 of 1986, it was the last year before the salary cap was introduced in the AFL at the start of 1987, when Brisbane and West Coast started.
All those 4 players on debut in Round 1 had great careers but Motley ended up playing 19 games and kicking 4 goals for Carlton in 1986-87, before a serious car crash ended his football career at the age of 22.
Apologies, I forgot to mention that Peter Kenny also made his debut for Carlton in Round 1, 1986, together with Craig Bradley, Jon Dorotich, Mil Hanna and Stephen Kernahan against Hawthorn at Waverley.
Peter Kenny ended up playing 11 games and kicking 20 goals for Carlton in 1986.
In Round 1 of 2025, Richmond had 3 players make their debut in Sam Lalor, Luke Trainor and Harry Armstrong against Carlton at the MCG. Luke Camporeale made his debut for Carlton in the same match.
What was notable for this game was that as Richmond was the home team, the milestone was the 60th anniversary of Richmond playing its first home match at the MCG in Round 1, 1965, having previously played home games at Punt Road Oval.
Richmond won by 13 points after overcoming a 41 point deficit during the match. Sam Lalor had 18 disposals, eight score involvements, two goals and two goal assists.
Harvey Dunn Jr. made his debut for Carlton against Collingwood at Princes Park in Round 8, 1951. Collingwood won by 14 points.
Dunn was notably the first player ever recruited under the father-son rule, he was residentially tied to North Melbourne, but his father, Harvey Dunn Sr., had played for 71 games and kicked 139 goals for Carlton from 1924-29. To avoid playing for North Melbourne, Dunn played for then-Eastern District Football League Club Box Hill, where Dunn Sr. was coach in 1949 and 1950, before receiving the father-son clearance to Carlton in 1951, once the rule was established.
Dunn ended up playing 9 games and kicked 4 goals for Carlton from 1951-54. He never played regular senior football for Carlton, and in 1954, he was cleared back to Box Hill in the VFA. He won the club best and fairest in 1955 and played there until 1959.
For the record Ron Barassi Jr. (debut for Melbourne in 1953) was the second person to debut under the father-son rule, when he successfully lobbied for the creation of a father-son-rule to allow clubs preferential recruiting access to the sons of players who have made a major past contribution to the team (50-game minimum at launch. Ron Barassi Sr. played 58 games and kicked 84 goals for Melbourne from 1936-40.
James Gowans made his debut for St Kilda against Fremantle at Subiaco, in Round 15 of 1999. Fremantle won by 23 points.
This match is notable for field umpire Peter Carey taking a “mark” during play, in his 299th match as an umpire. He was dropped as an umpire the following week and he ended up umpiring 307 games, including four VFL/AFL Grand Finals, as well as a VFA Grand Final. He was named the All-Australian umpire in 1992.
In the first quarter, Docker midfielder Adrian Fletcher gathered the ball next to the boundary line on the wing and turned inboard, spotting teammate Brad Wira free in the centre.
A beautiful pass was headed straight for his target when came an intercept from the unlikeliest of sources, none other than field umpire Peter Carey, who not only failed to get out of the way, but jumped slightly to take a very comfortable “mark”.
The stunned Wira threw out his arms in disbelief, while opponent Gavin Mitchell actually began to tackle Carey as though he was an opponent before the unthinkable registered. This “mark” by a field umpire had never happened in a VFL/AFL game before and hasn’t happened since.
James Gowans ended up playing 4 games and kicked 2 goals for St Kilda in 1999.
He then made a “mark” of his own by playing 245 games for Central Districts from 2000-2012. James Gowans played in all of the club’s nine SANFL premierships and won the Jack Oatey Medal when they claimed their first flag in 2000. He also won a Bob Quinn Medal in 2002 and the Central District’Best and Fairest’ award the following year.
Milan Faletic and Doug Cox both made their debut for St Kilda in Round 1, 1981 against Footscray at the Western Oval in 1981. St Kilda won by 49 points.
As far as Doug Cox was concerned, he was originally from South Mildura and played for West Torrens in the SANFL before joining St Kilda in 1981. His move to St Kilda proved controversial, as Richmond protested that he should have never made it to St Kilda because South Mildura was in Richmond’s country zone. As a result, St Kilda was stripped of eight premiership points and fined $5000; but, the VFL amended the relevant rules later in the season, and reinstated St Kilda’s points.
Despite the controversy, Cox ended up playing 39 games and kicked 1 goal for St Kilda from 1981-82. He later played 3 games for Essendon in 1983-84 and won the 1984 Grand a final sprint.
For the record, Milan Faletic, aged 28, kicked 5 goals for St Kilda against Footscray in his debut match, which coincided with Doug Cox’s debut for St Kilda. Faletic ended up playing 24 games and kicked 33 goals for St Kilda from 1981-82.
Thanks everyone for your alternatives and kind words.
Thanks Anon I did cover a few players that debut with legends, Robert Harvey is a legend and that was an oversight. Thank you for your other nominations there is some great ones there espeically James Gowns
Thanks Glen I was hoping you would know some prior to 1980 as you have a great memory.
Thanks Swish, I imagine Foyster debut maybe was low key considering other things that were happening. I wonder if he noticed if Plugger was nervous or not.
Thanks Luke and Damian for your kind words.