Grand final emergencies (Part 1 – 1980 to 1990)

 

Last year before the grand final I wrote on the ins and outs of grand final teams.

This year’s is based on the unlucky players that were named emergencies in a grand final side.

These players were close to playing in a grand final, but most did not get the opportunity in their careers.

As usual the names are from from 1980 onwards.

 

 

1980

Richmond –     Denis Collins, Michael Nugent, Ian Scrimshaw

Collingwood – Stuart Atkin, Des Herbert, David Twomey

 

Denis Collins

17 games in 1980

Last game Qualifying Final

147 games 1972-1980 (147 games played until 1980 Grand Final)

Collins played 100 games for Footscray from 1972-1977, 30 games for Carlton from 1978-1979 and 17 games for Richmond in 1980.

 

Michael Nugent

3 games in 1980

Last game in Round 13

16 games 1980-1981 (3 games played until 1980 Grand Final)

 

Ian Scrimshaw

6 games in 1980

Last game in Semi Final

59 games 1974-1981 (57 games played until 1980 Grand Final)

Scrimshaw was omitted for Bryan Wood. Scrimshaw played 19 games at Hawthorn from 1974-1975 and 40 games at Richmond from 1976-1981

 

Stuart Atkin

2 games in 1980

Last game in Elimination Final

18 games 1980-1983 (2 games played until 1980 Grand Final)

Played in 1981 Grand Final

 

Des Herbert

5 games in 1980

Last game in Round 20

22 games 1980-1983 (5 games played until 1980 Grand Final)

Herbert played 8 games at Collingwood from 1980 to mid 1981 before being traded with Leigh Carlson to Fitzroy for Warwick Irwin where he played 14 games from Mid 1981-1983.

 

David Twomey

7 games in 1980

Last game in Preliminary Final

63 games 1979-1985 (10 games played until 1980 Grand Final)

Played in 1981 Grand Final

Twomey was omitted for Ricky Barham

 

1981

Carlton – Barry Armstrong, Robert Klomp

Collingwood – Kevin Morris, Ronnie Wearmouth, Mark Weideman

Scott Howell replaced Geoff Southby in the selected side for Carlton

 

Barry Armstrong

10 games in 1981

Last played in Round 21

204 games 1969-1981 (204 games played until 1981 Grand Final)

Played in 1972  and 1979 Premiership

 

Robert Klomp

10 games in 1981

Last played in Round 11

93 games 1979-1984 (57 games played until 1981 Grand Final)

1979 and 1982 Premiership

Klomp played 84 games for Carlton between 1979-1984 before switching to Footscray half way through 1984 where he played nine games. Klomp owns a Thorn 18 inch TV.

 

Kevin Morris

17 games in 1981

Last played in Qualifying Final

181 games 1971-1981 (181 games played until 1981 Grand Final)

1973 and 1974 Premierships and 1972 and 1980 Grand Finals

Morris played 110 games for Richmond from 1971-1976 and 71 games for Collingwood from 1978-1981.

 

Ronnie Wearmouth

8 games in 1981

Last played Round 20

186 games 1969-1981 (186 games until 1981 Grand Final)

Played in 1977, 1979 and 1980 Grand Finals

 

Mark Weideman

20 games in 1981

Last played Preliminary Final

28 games 1981-1984 (20 games until 1981 Grand Final)

Weidemann was omitted for Peter Moore.

 

1982

Carlton –  David Clarke, Frank Marchesani

Richmond – Phil Egan, Wayne Shand

Ken Sheldon replaced Rod Austin in the selected side at Carlton

Ian Sartori replaced Brian Taylor in the selected side at Richmond

 

David Clarke

9 games in 1982

Last played in Preliminary Final

211 games 1971-1982 (211 games until 1982 Grand Final)

Clarke with was dropped for the Grand Final for Wayne Johnston. Clarke played 202 games from 1971-1981 at Geelong and nine games for Carlton in 1982.

 

Frank Marchesani

16 games in 1982

Last played in Preliminary Final

52 games 1980-1985 (35 games until 1982 Grand Final)

Marchesani was omitted for Jim Buckley. Marchesani played 16 games with Fitzroy in 1980 and 36 games for Carlton from 1981-1985. Marchesani was traded to Essendon in 1986 but did not play a game.

 

Phil Egan

14 games in 1982

Last played in Semi Final

126 games 1982-1991 (14 games until 1982 Grand Final)

Egan was omitted from the semifinal team as Richmond made three changes with Jim Jess, Ian Sartori and Bruce Tempany coming in. Egan played 125 games at Richmond from 1982-1990 and 1 game at Melbourne in 1991.

 

Wayne Shand

5 games in 1982

Last played in Round 15

12 games 1982-1984 (5 games until 1982 Grand Final)

Shand was a half back flanker who went to Footscray in 1985 but never played a game there.

 

1983

Hawthorn – Kelvin Moore, David Polkinghorne, Russell Shields

Essendon – Ron Andrews, Frank Dunell

Alan Ezard replaced Bill Duckworth in the selected side at Essendon

 

Kelvin Moore

20 games in 1983

Last played in Round 22

300 games 1970-1984 (292 games until 1983 Grand Final)

Played in 1971, 1976 and 1978 Premierships and 1975 Grand Final

Moore was omitted for 1983 finals with Gary Ayres and Leigh Matthews returning to the side.

 

David Polkinghorne

20 games in 1983

Last played in Semi Final

164 games 1975-1984 (152 games until 1983 Grand Final)

Played in 1976 and 1978 Premierships

Polkinghorne a small defender, was omitted for Michael Byrne in the Grand Final and would be emergency again in the 1984 Grand Final.

 

Russell Shields

16 games in 1983

Last played in Round 22

20 games 1983, 1984 and 1988 (16 games until 1983 Grand Final)

Shields played 17 games for Hawthorn in 1983-1984 and 3 games for Footscray in 1988.

 

Ron Andrews

20 games in 1983

Last played in Semi final

157 games 1973-1984 (151 games until 1983 Grand Final)

Andrews played 151 games for Essendon and six games for Collingwood in 1984.

 

Frank Dunell

17 games in 1983

Last played in Preliminary Final

115 games 1979-1988 (34 games until 1983 Grand Final)

Played in 1984 Premiership

Dunell was omitted for Stephen Copping and Bryan Wood. Dunell played in 1984 and was emergency in 1985. Dunell played 100 games for Essendon from 1979-1986 and 15 games for Brisbane from 1987-1988.

 

1984

Essendon – Tony Buhagiar, Stephen Carey, Tony Elshaug

Hawthorn – Gary Buckenara, Chris Langford, David Polkinghorne

 

Tony Buhagiar

14 games in 1984

Last played in the Preliminary Final

108 games 1981-1985 (83 games until 1984 Grand Final)

Played in 1983 Grand Final

Buhagiar was omitted for Frank Dunell. Buhagiar played 83 games for Essendon from 1981-1984 and 25 games for Footscray in 1985.

 

Stephen Carey

20 games in 1984

Last played in Round 22

112 games 1980-1986 (88 games until 1984 Grand Final)

Played in 1985 Premiership and 1983 Grand Final

Carey played 105 games with Essendon from 1980-1986 and 7 games with Geelong in 1986 having been traded mid-year.

 

Tony Elshaug

15 games in 1984

Last played in Round 21

137 games 1979-1988 (81 games until 1984 Grand Final)

Played in 1985 Premiership

Elshaug played 66 games for Melbourne from 1979-1983, 65 games for Essendon 1984-1987 and six games at Collingwood in 1988.

 

Gary Buckenara

1 game in 1984

Last played in Round 22

154 games 1982-1990 (47 games until 1984 Grand Final)

Played in 1983, 1986, 1988 and 1989 Premierships and in 1987 Grand Final.

Buckenara injured his knee at the start of the 1983 Grand Final and spent the rest of the match in hospital. Buckenara was omitted for Rodney Eade.

 

Chris Langford

22 games in 1984

Last played in semi Final

303 games 1983-1997 (33 games until 1984 Grand Final)

Played in 1986, 1988, 1989 and 1991 premierships and 1985 and 1987 Grand Finals.

Chris Langford was warming up with the team when just before the team was about to run out, Allan Jeans taped him on the shoulder and told him he was not playing as Ian Paton who had changed and warmed up in a separate room emerged to run out for the team.

 

David Polkinghorne

12 games in 1984

Last played in Qualifying Final

164 games 1975-1984 (164 games until 1984 Grand Final)

Played in 1976 and 1978 Premierships

Polkinghorne was emergency as well for 1983 Grand Final

 

1985

Essendon – Frank Dunell, Shane Heard

Hawthorn – Gary Buckenara, Rodney Eade, Peter Knights

Neil Clarke replaced Merv Neagle in the selected side at Essendon

 

Frank Dunell

21 games in 1985

Last played in Round 22

115 games 1979-1988 (79 games until 1985 Grand Final)

Played in 1984 Premiership

Dunell was emergency in 1983 and bought into the side for the 1984 Grand Final. Dunell played 100 games for Essendon from 1979-1986 and 15 games for Brisbane from 1987-1988.

 

Shane Heard

11 games in 1985

Last played in Round 13

168 games 1977-1987 and 1991 (125 games until 1985 Grand Final)

Played in 1984 Premiership and 1983 Grand Final

 

Gary Buckenara

19 games in 1985

Last played in Semi Final

154 games 1982-1990 (66 games until 1985 Grand Final)

Buckenara was an emergency in 1984 Grand Final. Buckenara was one of four omissions for the Preliminary Final. Buckenara kicked eight goals in the reserves premiership that day.

 

Rodney Eade

21 games in 1985

Last played Preliminary Final

259 games 1976-1990 (199 games until 1985 Grand Final)

Eade played the Qualifying Final, injured in the semifinal, played in the Preliminary Final and was dropped for Michael Tuck in the grand final. Eade played 229 games for Hawthorn from 1976-1987 and 30 games for Brisbane from 1988-1990

 

Peter Knights

13 games in 1985

Last played in preliminary Final

264 games 1969-1985 (264 games until 1985 Grand Final)

Knights was dropped for the Grand Final for David O’Halloran and played in the reserves where he captained the reserves to a premiership.

 

1986

Hawthorn – Ray Jencke, Ken Judge, Chris Wittman

Carlton – Rohan Burke, Brad Shine, Stephen Silvagni

 

Ray Jencke

6 games in 1986

Last played in Preliminary Final

194 games 1986-1997 (6 games until 1986 Grand Final)

Played in 1991 Premiership and 1987 Grand Final

Jencke was replaced in the side by John Kennedy and was also emergency for 1989 Grand Final.

 

Ken Judge

15 games in 1986

Last played in Semi Final

89 games 1983-1988 (72 games until 1986 Grand Final)

Played in 1983 Premiership and 1984 and 1985 Grand Final

Judge played 72 games for Hawthorn from 1983-1986 and 17 games for Brisbane from 1987-1988.

 

Chris Wittman

9 games in 1986

Last played in Round 16

98 games 1986-1993 (9 games until 1986 Grand Final)

Played in 1988 and 1989 Premierships.

Wittman played 89 games for Hawthorn 1986-1992 and 9 games St Kilda 1993. Wittman was emergency in 1991 Grand Final.

 

Rohan Burke

5 games in 1986

Last played in Round 11

18 games 1981-1986 (18 games until 1986 Grand Final)

Burke was cleared to Richmond in 1987 but did not play a game.

 

Brad Shine

8 games in 1986

Last played in Round 8

23 games 1985-1988 (9 games until 1986 Grand Final)

Shine was also emergency in 1987 Grand Final.

 

Stephen Silvagni

13 games in 1986

Last played in Semi Final

312 games 1985-2001 (30 games until 1986 Grand Final)

Played in 1987 and 1995 Premiership and 1993 and 1999 Grand Final

Silvagni was dropped for the Grand Final for Ken Hunter after playing the last 13 games.

 

1987

Carlton – Jim Buckley, Darren Ogier, Brad Shine

Hawthorn – Richard Loveridge, James Morrissey

Darrin Pritchard replaced Jason Dunstall in the selected side at Hawthorn

 

Jim Buckley

2 games in 1987

Last played in Round 14

164 games 1976-1990 (146 games until 1987 Grand Final)

Played in 1979, 1981 and 1982 Premierships.

Buckley captained Carlton reserves to a premiership in 1987.

 

Darren Ogier

8 games in 1987

Last played in Round 17

23 games 1985-1989 (13 games until 1987 Grand Final)

Ogier played 13 games for Carlton from 1985-1987, 2 games for North Melbourne in 1988 and 8 games for Sydney in 1989.

 

Brad Shine

8 games in 1987

Last played in Round 18

23 games 1985-1988 (17 games until 1987 Grand Final.

Shine was an emergency in 1986 Grand Final.

 

Richard Loveridge

23 games in 1987

Last played in Preliminary Final

136 games 1982-1988 (119 games until 1987 Grand Final)

Played in 1983 and 1986 Premierships and 1984 and 1985 Grand Finals

Loveridge was dropped for Andy Collins and was emergency for 1988 Grand Final.

 

James Morrissey

9 games in 1987

Last played in Round 12

106 games 1984-1993 (10 games until 1987 Grand Final)

Played in 1988, 1989 and 1991 Premierships

Morrissey did not play a game in 1985 and 1986.

 

 

1988

Hawthorn – Dean Anderson, Richard Loveridge, Peter Russo

Melbourne – Tony Campbell, Dean Chiron, Doug Koop

 

Dean Anderson

3 games in 1988

Last played in Round 21

150 games 1988-1996 (3 games until 1988 Grand Final)

Played in 1989 and 1991 Premierships.

Anderson played 83 games for Hawthorn from 1988-1992 and 67 games for St Kilda from 1993-1996.

 

Richard Loveridge

15 games in 1988

Last played in round 22

136 games 1983-1989 (134 games until 1988 Grand Final)

Played in 1983 and 1986 Premierships and 1984 and 1985 Grand Finals

Loveridge was also emergency in 1987 Grand Final.

 

Peter Russo

8 games in 1988

Last played in Round 22

195 games 1978-1990 (162 games until 1988 Grand Final)

Played in 1978 and 1986 Premiership and 1984, 1985 and 1987 Grand Final

Russo played 162 games for Hawthorn from 1978-1988 and 33 games for St Kilda from 1989-1990

 

Tony Campbell

17 games in 1988

Last played in Round 21

118 games 1986-1996 (35 games until 1988 Grand Final)

Campbell played 75 games for Melbourne from1986-1991 and 43 games for Footscray from 1992-1996.

 

Dean Chiron

7 games in 1988

Last played in Round 17

37 games 1983-1989 (35 games until 1988 Grand Final)

Chiron played 19 games for St Kilda 1983-1984, 1 game Footscray 1986 and 17 games for Melbourne 1987-1989.

 

Doug Koop

7 games in 1988

Last played in Semi Final

44 games 1979-1988 (44 games until 1988 Grand Final)

Koop played 15 games at South Melbourne from 1979-1981, 5 games North Melbourne 1985-1986 and 24 games at Melbourne 1987-1988.

 

1989

Hawthorn – Paul Dear, Robert Dickson, Ray Jencke

Geelong – Martin Christensen, Austin McCrabb, Darren Morgan

 

Paul Dear

5 games in 1989

Last played in Round 22

123 games 1987-1996 (14 games until 1989 Grand Final)

Played in 1991 Premiership and played in 1987 Grand Final

Dear won the Norm Smith Medal in 1991.

 

Robert Dickson

6 games in 1989

Last played in Round 22

19 games 1988-1991 (13 games until 1989 Grand Final)

Dickson played 17 games from 1988-1990 and 2 games for Brisbane in 1991.

 

Ray Jencke

10 games in 1989

Last played in Round 21

194 games 1986-1997 (53 games until 1989 Grand Final)

Played in 1991 Premiership and 1987 Grand Final

Jencke was also emergency in 1986 Grand Final

 

Martin Christensen

0 games in 1989

71 games 1985-1992 (60 games until 1989 Grand Final)

Christensen played 69 games for Geelong 1985-1991 and 2 games for North Melbourne in 1992

 

Austin McCrabb

8 games in 1989

Last played in Round 20

45 games 1987-1992 (15 games until 1989 Grand Final)

McCrabb played 36 games for Geelong 1987-1991 and 9 games for Hawthorn in 1992.

 

Darren Morgan

21 games in 1989

Last played in Qualifying Final

92 games 1984-1990 (79 games until 1989 Grand Final)

Morgan was traded to Sydney in 1990 and Footscray in 1991 but never played a game there.

 

1990

Collingwood – Paul Hawke, Ron McKeown

Essendon – Dean Bailey, David Flood, Michael Werner

Shane Kerrison replaced Alan Richardson in the selected side at Collingwood

 

Paul Hawke

0 games in 1990

114 games 1984-1991 (113 games until 1990 Grand Final)

Hawke played 73 games for Sydney from 1984-1987 and 1991 and 41 games for Collingwood 1988-1989

 

Ron McKeown

20 games in 1990

Last played in 1990 Qualifying Final replay

123 games 1984-1993 (84 games until 1990 Grand Final)

 

Dean Bailey

0 games in 1990

53 games 1986-1992 (43 games until 1990 Grand Final)

 

David Flood

2 games in 1990

Last Played in Round 16

58 games 1986-1995 (15 games until 1990 Grand Final)

Flood was also emergency in 1993.

 

Michael Werner

14 games in 1990

Last played in Round 21

60 games 1989-1994 (26 games until 1990 Grand Final)

Werner played 40 games for Essendon from 1989-1992 and 20 games for Sydney from 1993-1994

 

 

 

 

To return to our Footy Almanac home page click HERE.

 

Our writers are independent contributors. The opinions expressed in their articles are their own. They are not the views, nor do they reflect the views, of Malarkey Publications.

 

 

Do you enjoy the Almanac concept?

And want to ensure it continues in its current form, and better? To help things keep ticking over please consider making your own contribution.

Become an Almanac (annual) member – click HERE.