BBL06 – The Other Elephant In The Room

On a balmy Melbourne evening, where the temperature was around 25°C at game time, a healthy crowd of more than 26,000 people filed into Etihad Stadium. The Hobart Hurricanes were coming to town, and weren’t going to go down without a fight. A few people came from work, others who haven’t returned for 2017 yet may have visited local watering holes, and of course, plenty of families cruised around West Melbourne looking for somewhere to park for free.

The crowd was a sea of red, fans showing their support for their Melbourne Renegades, who were going to bat first. However, not before a sea of Bollywood Dancers took the field, showing their skills and forming a guard of honour. Plus there was an elephant. Not a real elephant, but a pretty impressive costume of one. And it didn’t get spooked by the crowd.

The Renegades came out and batted impressively from the start. Aaron Finch hit the ball to all corners in a well-paced half century, and was supported early by Cameron White. After the departure of the latter, it was up to Tom Cooper to finish off the innings, which he did with aplomb, scoring a blistering 53 of 24 deliveries. Amassing a total of 4/222, the Renegades had set a new Big Bash League record, and the local fans were happy. It was time to enjoy some more Bollywood dancing, and other sponsor promotions on the arena.

Then the Hurricanes came out. Two early wickets to pinch-hitting bowler Tom Cooper had the visitors at 2/19, and on the ropes. The Renegades had their foot on the throat, and were going for the kill. Hobart were well and truly gone. No chance. Game, effectively, over. Well, someone forgot to mention that part of the storyline to Ben McDermott and George Bailey, the former scoring not only his maiden T20 ton, but a first for his club, and a BBL record score too. The experienced Bailey’s job was just to get out of the way.

By the time the match was over, the Hurricanes had done the impossible. They had chased down the total on the final ball, when no one except perhaps McDermott had given them a chance. When the much-hated Stuart Broad hit the winning runs, and walked off the field – yes, he actually knows how to walk, which surprised everyone – viewers and so-called experts were calling this one of the greatest matches in the BBL’s short history.

Well, as fans filed out of Melbourne’s second-largest stadium, there wasn’t a feeling of positivity, nor did most fans feel as though they had witnessed something special.

This brings me to the other elephant in the room. Cricket Australia, along with the Big Bash League, has tried to manufacture a competition with genuine rivalries. They have told their fans to be passionate. Be proud. Get behind your team. Be tribal. Be parochial. Show your colours. For Renegades fans: #GetOnRed. Support your team, and help them get over the line.

If this match were an AFL match, it would be like going in at half time with a 10-goal lead, and then surrendering it in the second half. If you were a fan of the losing team, would you walk out saying, “Hey, that was fantastic to watch!”? No! You’d be fuming, and would probably consider buying a truckload of chicken manure to dump on your club’s doorstep.

Is this all just sour grapes from a sore loser? Perhaps. But is that the fault of the fans? Definitely not. If Cricket Australia and the Big Bash League want genuine passion and rivalries, they need to expect that fans of a club that loses a match in this manner will be disappointed. The clubs need to understand this too, and empathise with their members and fans, not be pushing how good a spectacle the night was.

When I look at my shelves of DVDs, all of the football ones show my club winning. No close losses in great games. Only wins. Because that’s what sport is all about. And last night was a loss for the Melbourne Renegades.

Finch 63 (40), Cooper 53 (24), Reed 2/54 (4.0)

McDermott 114 (52), Bailey 59 (42), Narine 3/27 (4.0)

Melbourne Renegades: Finch, Cooper, Narine
Hobart Hurricanes: McDermott, Bailey

Umpires: Gillespie, Wilson

My Votes: 3 McDermott (HH); 2 Cooper (MR); 1 Bailey (HH).


  1. Yvette Wroby says

    Hi Kent, I’m not a “supporter” or “fan” so as a casual onlooker, it was superb. Did feel very sorry for the Red’s though. They’d set such a high score, and the game means they are out of the competition? Understand your loss.

    Well written

  2. Peter Warrington says

    McDermott’s tonking was ridiculous. Interesting to see a lineup bereft of quicks.

    Tim Paine scoring the best primary ever.

    I thought Narine was just about BOG, he is harder to read than Ulysses. 3-for and 7 an over when most going for 12 was heroic.

    Stuey Broad interviewed afterwards, a fine and humble young man with a taste for Australian nickers.

    Patto has perfected the scowl in his time away. Bowled like someone prepping for India. Not sure why some of these guys get a game in this format. He needs to talk to Hilfy about taking up the legspin in this format.

  3. I think what’s happening with support in the BBL is that we’re moving towards an NBA style support, where fans are more influenced by the players involved. When a in-form player catches fire social media lights up as words gets around that you need to tune in. Now sure, I think loyalty in sport is the bedrock of the ongoing success for any comp & I think in time it will occur in the BBL but what’s happening with all the T20 comps right now is that team rosters change significantly from one season to the next which means players come & go constantly. Anecdotally it does appear that quite a few folks have duel memberships to the Renegades & Stars in Melbourne , which to me means not necessarily divided loyalty but more a love of watching T20 live & enjoying seeing KP or dare I say, Chris Gayle, do what they do best.

  4. Good read. I went to bed last night with the Hurricanes 2 for not many and was horrified to find the result this morning. The Bash has caught my imagination and am a fervent fan.

  5. I don’t know what test cricket has come to these days when the game is over in just 40 overs! And whats with all these brightly coloured shirts! And anyway I don’t reckon scores of 220+ are much good, a proper test team would go on to make 500+. I suppose the second innings is getting rained off today then? And don’t get me started on the elephant, i mean a bloody elephant! Whats wrong with a cup of tea and a cheese sandwich?


  6. Dave Brown says

    Interesting read, Kent. Hypothesis I have been working on – Victorians are not used to “choosing” a team, rather have had the privilege of growing up with one. As a result, the need to engage meaningfully with something new is not something that comes naturally (even in the case of the A-League Victorians only had the Victory at the start which is why they have three times as many members as any other club). Whereas for the rest of us Aussie Rules types (other than Port Adelaide supporters), the concept of choosing or adopting a team was thrust upon us long ago if we wanted to passionately follow an AFL side. The end result being adopting our local BBL franchise is much more natural. Hence why Adelaide Oval, the Gabba, the WACA and Bellerive sell out their BBL games and their punters go home properly disappointed when they lose.

Leave a Comment