Almanac Football: 1993 Revisited

Has anyone else been listening to “The Greatest Season That Was:93”, a multi-episode podcast by Shannon Gill, Dan Brettig and Adam Collins about the 1993 AFL season?


(JTH – your name gets a mention at the end of Episode 9, along with some suggestions about the need for further reminiscences at the Clyde and/or North Fitzroy Arms).


It’s a ripper series that features extended interviews with coaches, administrators and journalists from the time, providing lots of fascinating insights into an era that in some ways feels like yesterday. Yet hearing some of the stories underscores just how little the game and the competition had emerged from its amateur days.


The hosts have deliberately chosen 1993 as their focus because it represents for them the pinnacle of footy played at its purest.  That said, the theme of the series is more about how 1993 was a point at which many aspects of footy’s old ways were butting up against the relentless forces that were transforming the AFL into a nation-wide big business. It was the last year in which Fitzroy was a competitive unit and the first year that Adelaide made finals. Matches were still being played at old suburban grounds like Victoria Park and Moorabbin. It was the first year in which a final was played at night. It was a time when many players and coaches still held down “real” jobs, but the money in the game was making professionalism a reality.  It was the year in which old-timers railed against the introduction of a sponsor’s logo (McDonalds) on the football. Critically, it was the year in which the League made the fateful decision to save Sydney from oblivion and to grant player concessions to fellow strugglers, Brisbane and Richmond, moves that would ultimately set these clubs on the path to future success. At the same time, it denied support to the near bankrupt Fitzroy because their team was “too strong” to be eligible. Three years later, that club was no more.


I’ll leave the story-telling about the season to the podcast. But it’s piqued my interest sufficiently to dig out some old videotapes that preserve several of the more memorable games from 1993. In the light of the endless debate in 2018 about the quality of football and the need for rule changes to make it more attractive, I was intrigued. How would the best of 25 years ago stack up?


The games I had a look at were, for the most part, among the best matches of the season. The exception was a Richmond v Brisbane match which is an eminently forgettable contest, save for the interesting curio of Michael Voss and Nathan Buckley playing as team-mates for the Bears. What might have been, Bucks!


I found highlights of the famous early season draw between Essendon v Carlton, a free-wheeling 39 goal shoot-out, which gave the first real insight into what these rejuvenated sides would offer. It’s fair to say that Stephen Kernahan features fairly prominently in my 1993 revisit, and when you look at his aerial supremacy and goal-kicking prowess(68 in 1993), it’s staggering to think that he wasn’t within cooee of the top goalkickers of the season. This day of course was famous for one of Sticks’ less than glorious moments, as he shanked his post-siren shot for goal out of bounds, when any score would have won the game for Carlton. His opponent that day was 17-year old Dustin Fletcher in just his second game.


Redemption came quickly for Sticks as he slotted the matchwinner against Hawthorn the very next week in front of an adoring Robert Heatley Stand at Princes Park. Another high quality game between two of the eventual finalists, it’s one of several examples where I was reminded of the understated methodical genius of Jason Dunstall who slotted his 800th goal in this game. His ability to lead and mark under duress (on this occasion against Fullback of the Century, Stephen Silvagni) and convert with metronomic efficiency is awesome.


Dunstall failed to get the Hawks across the line in this game but he went one better in the next game I looked at, a wet Friday night game against new glamour team, North Melbourne. While the commentators are frothing about “Duck”, “Horse” and the mercurial Adrian McAdam at one end, it’s Dunstall who keeps the Hawks in it, before snaring two marks in the final couple of minutes and winning the game with a goal from the second of these. It was one of several top notch Friday night contests in 1993 that catapulted this timeslot from “graveyard” to “prime time”.


Another Friday night special is North’s match against Essendon and it’s my pick of the 1993 action that I reviewed. A breathtakingly relentless contest in which North shot out of the blocks, only to be reeled in the Bombers who take complete control through the middle stages but are let down by poor conversion. North surge late and end up running away by 38 points thanks to some Longmire and Carey theatrics. In these days of barely a dozen contested marks per game, it’s worth checking out some of this old footage to see what these guys were capable of. Carey running back into the oncoming pack and emerging with the ball still gives me goosebumps. Remarkably, his opponent for much of the night is the veteran Tim Watson. Bomber fans might be interested to recall that Bradley Plain slotted an impressive 4 goals in a losing team.


My stash also includes most of the finals including Adelaide’s improbably gutsy maiden final and win against Hawthorn. It’s a pity that this wasn’t a great day for their star spearhead, Tony Modra, and that I don’t have any of his more celebrated goalfests that made Modra “bigger than Bradman” in Adelaide. Still it’s worth watching if only to remind oneself that the Crows were far more than a one-man team during that great season. Stuart Wigney, Randall Bone and Matthew Liptak were among the important contributors that day, whilst a midfield highlight was Jarman v Jarman. Wow!


Sadly, my tape of Carlton’s epic 2 point win over Essendon is very grainy, but it’s clear enough to appreciate the forward and midfield masterclasses put on by Messrs Kernahan and Williams. The Bombers were missing Hird, Misiti, Fletcher and Thompson that night but still almost prevailed. Wanganeen was superb in defence.


Essendon’s thrilling Preliminary Final comeback to defeat Adelaide receives plenty of coverage even today, and I need say no more than that the replay stands the test of time. But I reckon their Semi-Final win over West Coast was even more impressive as the young Bombers overcame the disappointment of the previous week to take down the reigning Premiers, slicing through the tough Eagles defence in a triumph of youthful exuberance over experience.


Carlton’s win over Adelaide was a more pedestrian affair at a windy Waverley but Craig Bradley’s five goal haul, including three pivotal goals into the wind in the third quarter, was brilliant in the conditions. I must mention that I once had the occasion to replay Justin Madden’s famous “galloping giraffe” goal from this game as an introduction to the man himself when, as Minister for Sport, he graciously spoke at my work’s footy tipping prize presentation. His typically jovial response was, in his words, “what the tape doesn’t show is that I was that buggered after that run that I could scarcely get back to contest the next centre bounce”!


After such an exciting selection, the ’93 Grand Final is a bit of an anti-climax unless of course you’re a Bombers tragic, although it’s worth another look after hearing the bizarre story from David Parkin on the podcast about the famous Neale Daniher’s dossier that supposedly unpicked Carlton’s centre bounce strategy. Seeing some of Michael Long’s earlier games that season puts his Norm Smith Medal performance into perspective: it was a continuation of his great form throughout the year. And for all that Dean Wallis made a (forceful) contribution in the big game, you only have to look at a few of Derek Kickett’s wonderful cameos in earlier matches to find the decision to drop him for the GF absolutely gobsmacking.


In summary, the games I looked at were fast, highly skilled (especially foot skills), and I have no doubt would be entertaining even to younger fans reared solely on post-millennium footy. In general play, the action is fast and open with few of the ugly packs and scrimmages that blight the modern game. It raises the interesting question of whether the players then were better skilled or whether they were simply able to execute their skills better because they were under less pressure.


But the biggest difference between then and now is the incredible array of power forwards and their significance to their teams. For example, I haven’t even mentioned Tony Lockett (injured and suspended for a fair bit of 1993) or G. Ablett’s century of goals kicked in fewer games than any player except Bob Pratt and the extraordinary statistic of kicking bags of 10, 11 and 14 in losing sides! It was staggering to hear recently that Jason Dunstall, who won the 1993 Coleman Medal that year with over 120 goals, didn’t even make the All-Australian side!


In part, I think we have to conclude that there was just an amazing cluster of great forwards at that time, rather than simply bemoan the changes to the game that have reduced their impact. In my review I saw plenty of thrilling one-on-one battles between these stars and their defensive counterparts, but 2018 Stainless scratches his head at the naïve acceptance of such dominance by the spearheads and looks in vain for tactical moves to stop them: the double-teaming, the zones, the presses of the modern game that have countered this offensive superiority in recent years. I wonder how the Chief would go today against Alex Rance and, more pertinently, the structures that Rance orchestrates around him?


My final observation is about crowd involvement. In contrast with the often eerily quiet days and nights that I experience regularly today even with 80,000 in the house, the crowds back then seem to be yelling themselves hoarse (judging from the sound effects). It suggests a genuine passion about the game and a reckless joie de vivre that we don’t often see today.


All in all, a fascinating trip down memory lane.


Do you love the Almanac concept?
And want to ensure it continues in its current form, and better? To help keep things ticking over please consider making your own contribution.

One off financial contribution – CLICK HERE
Regular financial contribution (monthly EFT) – CLICK HERE
Become an Almanac (annual) member – CLICK HERE



About Sam Steele

50 years a Richmond supporter. Enjoying a bounteous time after 37 years of drought. Should've been a farmer!


  1. Mark 'Swish' Schwerdt says

    Great summary here Stainless. I haven’t yet heard the latest episode (Bruce Eva on Nicky Winmar), but the honesty of the interviewees of the podcast in the other episodes is striking, as is the number of times they mention to the interviewers “you’ve really done your homework here”.

    The Cameron Schwab episode is extraordinarily raw and Robert Shaw rollicks along with revelation after revelation. But they are all exciting to listen to.

    Much of their archival material comes from YouTube and the well crafted sound bites adds vivid colour to the dialogue.

    1993 was my last season full season in Adelaide, attending all of their home games. This podcast helps me realise how fortunate I was to see it unfold live.

  2. Collins, Brettig and Gill et al are doing a wonderful job with this.
    It is a ripper of a podcast.

  3. george smith says

    Was not a good year for Collingwood, they started off well beating Footscray, Essendon and Carlton, but it was all downhill from there. Ran into North Melbourne and were absolutely belted, Adrian Macadam went nuts in one of those black days for Collingwood which was the measuring stick on how not to for years. Soon to be premiers Essendon followed it up with their first defeat of the Pies since 1990, another awful performance from the black and white brigade.

    I went to the Collingwood v Carlton match with my young nephew, yet another woeful performance, this time featuring a huge rainstorm in the third quarter which killed the contest – Showponies easily. Fortunately or sadly this did not diminish my nephew’s enthusiasm for the Magpies.

    Add to this Nicky Winmar and the racial abuse controversy, Daicos’s last year and it is certainly a year most Magpies prefer to forget.

  4. Thanks for the comments.
    Swish – I remember attending the Crows’ finals in Melbourne and being most impressed with them. I can only imagine what the vibe must have been like at Footy Park that year. You’re right about the honesty of the interviews. Nothing like the passage of time to loosen tongues!
    Smokie – I dare say you’d have some great memories of ’93, with North really starting their dominant phase through the decade?
    George – forgettable year for you and me both. Richmond had four wins for the year and copped some absolute beltings along the way. The emergence of Richo and making the pre-season GF were the only highlights.

  5. Friday nights at the G. Twas a great time to be a Roos supporter!

  6. Good work Stainless. I was a Geelong supporter in those days of yore. 1993 was the year in between GF losses to the Weagles.

    The year started slowly with wins and losses interspersing each other, though the Cats finished the season on a roll, with a sterling victory over the Weagles in Perth. Despite being a season in which they missed the finals , they beat their nemesis Hawthorn twice, the first time for over a decade. The highlight of that year was the great number 5; GOD.

    He’d played much of his career up forward, as a roaming half forward flank, sometimes as full forward, but this was the year Malcolm Blight played him as a permanent full forward: a position he retained until the end of his career.

    He kicked 124 goals in 17 games. He brought up his 50 goals in only 6 games equalling Bob Pratt’s long held record, then reached his ton in 14 games. Five times he kicked 10 or more, including that 14.7 against Essendon in the shoot out @ the G: How did Geelong lose ? Not bad for a chap who’d just turned 31. This was the first of three consecutive seasons of 100+ goals.


  7. Hi Glen
    I was at the game at the MCG in 1993 when Ablett kicked 11 against Melbourne and Geelong lost a shootout by 20 goals to 22! Unbelievable!
    I’m pretty sure I only went to this game to see him play.

  8. Luke Reynolds says

    Stainless, I’m absolutely loving the podcast. 1993 was the year I first saw footy at Victoria Park.
    I was an early teen in these years, my favourite football was played in the years 1992, 93 & 94. The game was magnificent to watch.
    As George mentioned, ’93 holds some sadness as it saw the end of the career of my childhood (and still now) hero, Peter Daicos. The Daicos v Ablett shootout at Victoria Park in 1993, the final great game from the Macedonian Marvel, is possibly my favourite game of Australian Rules ever played.
    But got so much joy out of watching Ablett and Modra in ’93. And the always entertaining North Melbourne (McAdam!!).

  9. DBalassone says

    Magic time. I think of Ablett & Carey when I think of ’93. The Cats beat the Eagles in the final game of that season but somehow still missed the final 6. I reckon they could have done some damage. And North could have easily won the flag that year but copped the Eagles at VFL Park in week 1 (a ground the Eagles loved). I was there that night game when Carey destroyed the Bombers. He was unstoppable. Hard to believe Dons would go on to win the flag.

    Ablett 124 goals from 17 games. Averaged more than 7 a game. Only Lockett 127 goals from 17 games in ’91 and Pratt 150 goals from 21 games in ’34 are in that company. I’m still a bit bemused that you can’t buy a DVD that shows all the highlights from Ablett’s career (I know there’s one for his ’93 season). It would sell a truckload.

Leave a Comment