Almanac Cricket- The Day the West Indies Were Bowled Out For 25. By Ireland.

It’s one of those scorecards which demands a second and third glance.

You can almost image the continuity man – and in these days, they were ALL men – asking: “Is this a joke?”

But no, there really was a day where all the forces in the cricket world aligned as the catalyst for a miracle. And, even now, nearly 50 years later, there are still witnesses to the astonishing day when the West Indies were bowled out for 25 by Ireland.

I was in Aberdeen on Thursday and started chatting to an amiable gentleman with a lilting Irish accent. He was interested by the various pieces of memorabilia around the bar area: the signed bat bearing Sir Richard Hadlee’s name and the old photographs of a packed ground as thousands turned up to watch Don Bradman and his “Invincibles” play in the Granite City.

But then, he turned the conversation to another topic and I discovered this gent had been among the crowd at Sion Mills in his homeland on that extraordinary day 47 years ago.

Even at this juncture, it sounds implausible. Yes, the Caribbean maestros had rested some of their leading luminaries, including the talismanic Garry Sobers, Roy Frdericks and Lance Gibbs.

But they were still packed with star performers, as you might expect of a team on the verge of becoming the greatest in the world throughout the 1970s.

And, in these days, there was no Associate structure, no tradition of countries such as the Irish, Scots or Dutch jousting with giants with any true aspirations of victory.

Yet, as my new friend David Anderson told me: “We always thought our boys could bother anybody if the conditions were in our favour. And they definitely were that morning. It had poured with rain the night before and the wicket was very green.

“Nowadays, any team would have asked the opposition to bat first on a surface like that, but there were thousands of fans in the ground and most of them wanted to see the West Indies bat. It was just the way things were done. So they batted and they made a horrible mess of it.”

In the intervening 47 years, the Irish have grown accustomed to causing seismic ripples and have defeated the West Indies in a World Cup by scoring over 300. But that 1969 collective were all amateurs, who had to combine work with willowy commitments.

And yet, as I was told, they had no shortage of natural talent, allied to lashings of pride, passion and positivity. Basil Butcher looked a trifle worried as it was confirmed the tourists would bat. 90 minutes later, he would be more than just worried.

The home attack was led by left-armer Alec O’Riordan and the team’s captain Douglas Goodwin. They were soon in their pomp and revelling in unprecedented deeds of derring-do.

Mind you, the West Indians didn’t exactly help their cause. Joey Carew immediately played a horrible shot, and Steve Camacho was equally indisciplined, as they attempted some T20-style hoicks. Neither overstayed his welcome and Butcher walked to the crease with the score at one for 2.

As Anderson told me: “We never thought it would turn out the way it did, but you couldn’t say they looked ready to fight. Some of us thought Butcher and his partner [Maurice Foster] would get their heads down and graft for a bit, but he [Foster] ran himself out, and it just got worse for them.

“Butcher went next, although he got a bloody good ball and he didn’t throw it away. O’Riordan didn’t look like a top-class bowler, but he knew where to put the ball and he loved conditions like that.”

At six for 4, the Windies didn’t. Clive Lloyd, a towering colossus of the sport, a man who subsequently hoisted the World Cup and reigned over the ICC’s superpowers, was next to go, the victim of another injudicious shot, and half the side were out for half a dozen.

Soon enough, their plight worsened. Clyde Walcott, one of the fabled Three Ws, with Everton Weekes and Frank Worrell, had emerged from retirement to delight the crowds, but instead scratched and scraped around for a painful six before being put out of his misery by O’Riordan.

And, even as the spectators looked on in disbelief, another three wickets were lost as the West Indies succumbed to 12 for 9.

“Their last man [Grayson Shillingford] hit the first boundary of the innings, but everything was a bit surreal by that stage, and the [BBC] TV cameramen knew they had something historic on their hands,” recalled Anderson.

“He [Shillingford] made the top score [of nine not out], but the other lad [Philbert Blair] was bowled by Goodwin and it was all over. 25 all out in 25 overs [and three balls]! Well, none of us could credit it. But we knew we had just seen something that would never be repeated.”

A little matter of 47 years later, this blithe fellow still sounded boyish talking about it. O’Riordan’s figures were 13-8-18-4. Goodwin’s were even more impressive – 12.3-8-6-5. And the Irish knocked off the runs for the loss of just one wicket.

As my confrere concluded: “You have to give the West Indians some praise: they stayed and played on for the rest of the day when they must have just wanted to head to the bar. It was fantastic, one of the greatest days of my life.”

Then we went over to have another look at the Invincibles. It was a good meeting, a chance to delve into the past. And the Irish have the opportunity to make fresh history when they tackle Sri Lanka in two ODIs next week.

Chances are that it won’t make the BBC news headlines though!


  1. Neil Drysdale says

    This was one of the most remarkable days in the whole history of cricket. It was good to talk to somebody who was there.

  2. Great piece Neil – low-scoring cricket matches are often the most memorable and this one highlights why. Can’t imagine there were too many in the crowd that day, well done for having the luck to find one (don’t they say you make your own luck?) … Let alone find one all these years later!

  3. Amazing result this Neil. We need to remember it predates ODI’s as we know by 18 months. The first ODI being played between Australia and England at the “G” replacing the washed out third test of the 1970-71 Ashes series.

    Considering the parlous state of the current Widies side, a score like this is not beyond the realms of possibility.


  4. Luke Reynolds says

    Fantastic read Neil, remember first hearing about this result as a child in the 1980’s during the West Indies peak era and thinking that there was no way it could be true!
    Also staggering to think Ireland could do something like that then basically not get a look in on the world stage until 2007.

  5. A game i’m interested in was when Holland beat Australia in the Hague back in 1964. This followed the tour of England where we won the test series 1-0.

    In the match in the Hague Australian batsmen Jack Potter got his skull fractured effectively putting a kybosh to his career.

    Does anybody know much about this encounter?


  6. Barry McAdam says

    What a well written story Neil. I remember it happening, and was there rumours of a Windies bender the night before?

  7. Neil Drysdale says

    Hi Glen, this was another big shock in the early days of one-day games, but it hasn’t gained as much publicity as the WI game because it followed a more conventional pattern.

    A strong Australian line-up including Norman O’Neill, Bobby Simpson, Bob Cowper, Peter Burge and Wally Grout, struggled to make a big score, but eventually got to 197.

    However, the Dutch openers put on 99 for the first wicket and despite a subsequent collapse, they won by three wickets, with Cowper being smashed for 17 off 5 balls to settle the outcome.

    There were over 15,000 fans at the contest.

Leave a Comment