One Hundred Years Ago: Round 7, 5th June, 1911

Monday the 5th of June 1911 was the 46th birthday of King George V, necessitating the footballers of the Victorian Football League to drag their weary bones out of bed and play a second round of football games in the space of three days. It goes without saying that there was no AFLPA back in those days.

Though Melbourne was without a visit from King George, another king had perchance arrived in time for the holiday. ‘American March King’ John Phillip Sousa was in town with his band for a series of concerts and the marching band fraternity gathered in their hundreds at Spencer St station to greet him. Following the obligatory speeches, the massed ensemble marched through the centre of town to give locals a taste of military pomp with a Yankee flavour.

Sadly for Mr Sousa, Melbourne’s weather was no respecter of visitors or footballers: the day was the coldest of the year so far and heavy rain fell most of the morning. Combined with the short break between games, conditions seemed tailor-made for some upsets.

Feature match of the round saw 2nd placed Fitzroy host 5th placed South Melbourne in front of a hardy holiday crowd of 18,000. The Bloods had slipped down the ladder after successive narrow losses.

It transpired that three days was a long time in football, as the Fitzroy ‘Phoenix’ of Saturday crashed heavily into the Brunswick St mud on Monday. South kicked into the wind but led at ¼ time, and thereafter the game became a procession as the visitors overwhelmed their opponents to win by 48 points.

This abrupt turnaround in form was largely due to two very divergent characters in South colours.

Bruce Moses Farquhar Sloss was then playing only the 19th game of a career that would eventually see The Encyclopedia of VFL/AFL Footballers dub him the ‘James Hird of his era’. At 181cm and 76kgs, he dominated as a follower (what later became known as ruck-rover) this afternoon and many others. Born in East Malvern, he failed to make a mark in an early try with Essendon, before starring in the VFA with Brighton. Once South managed to get him a clearance he never looked back.

Combining matinee idol looks, sound education and natural leadership qualities with his playing ability, Sloss became one of the stars of the league. Famously he almost singlehandedly sparked a South comeback in the 1914 grand final which only just failed to snatch victory from Carlton. That would be his last league game. A prized catch for the army, he’d already enlisted and was to die on the fields of France aged just 28.

Dominating Fitzroy alongside Sloss was Richard ‘Dick’ Casey, a Brunswick born Blood of very different nature and inclination. Casey was a jockey-sized 168cm and 58kgs, but known as a ‘smart, combative and aggressive footballer’ prone to provoking both opposition and press. In 1910 he had indirectly caused enormous controversy after a round 6 game. Reported for striking and charging, Casey was suspended for the rest of the season. South’s champion follower Bert Franks had attended the tribunal meeting and was inflamed upon hearing the verdict. He vented his feelings towards umpire Lardy Tulloch (an ex Magpie player) and found himself suspended ‘during the pleasure of the league’. He did not play again until 1912.  The loss of both players was a big factor in South’s loss to Collingwood in the 1910 preliminary final.

Casey was on his best behaviour this afternoon and along with Sloss – and 5 goals from Len Mortimer- was too much for an overwhelmed Fitzroy. Jack Furness kicked 2 of the Maroon’s 3 goals and ‘Tunner’ Reardon was again their best.

A large Carlton contingent accompanied the team by steamer and rail to Corio, where the Blues took on the Pivotonians. ‘Constant rain in the forenoon’ was followed by heavy rain after first bounce. Just to cap it off, 10 minutes of fierce hail followed later.

Given the conditions, it was little surprise Vin Gardiner missed with his first two place-kick attempts for Carlton. He found his range, but his 3 goals were only enough to see the visitors up by a goal at half time.

At the break Geelong, who had faltered in the third term the previous week against Essendon, were ‘enjoined to go all they were worth on resuming’. They did, producing a third term that saw them 18 points clear at the final change; too much to be overhauled in the rain.

Dick Grigg ‘followed up his sterling performance on Saturday by another fine exhibition fair and good’. Alec Eason kicked 3 goals, George Heinz again roved effectively, Harry Marsham rucked well, and Billy Orchard also starred. For the Blues, their smaller brigade of Viv Valentine, Gardiner, and Roy Johnson were best.

University travelled to a very muddy Victoria Park to battle the Magpies in front of a ‘moderate’ crowd. Atypical of Victoria Park some might say. Collingwood proceeded to kick 2.10 in the first term. The Students managed goals with their first two shots and hung in until half time. After the break Collingwood broke away and the final quarter became ‘willing’, with University ‘contributing their share of the willingness’. It is likely class differences were finding old expression.

Willing or not, the Pies won comfortably by 26 points, with Jims Sadler and Sharp dominant across half back, McHale controlling the centre and Paddy Rowan filling in well in the ruck for the missing George Angus. Baxter, Gilchrist, Ryan and Wilson all kicked a brace. For University, the defenders ‘had the largest share of work to do’- notably Jack Gray, George Elliot and Ted Cordner. Ken McLeod ‘bore and gave his share of most of the trouble’ in kicking 2 goals, whilst followers Brake and Greenham ‘did most of the football’.

Melbourne and Richmond enjoyed better conditions at the MCG, and 8,130 spectators saw a free-flowing and even battle for three quarters, before the Tigers continued their revival by outlasting the Fuchsias in the final term. Their followers showed ‘great stamina’ in ‘having the better of the finishing struggle’- notably Barney Herbert, Syd Reeves and James Mahoney. New skipper Len Incigneri again shone. Fuchsias Vin Coutie and Wally Naismith both played well in their respective 150th games.

Essendon hosted St Kilda at East Melbourne and scored the first 20 points before the visitors ‘inspired the scorer to an effort on their behalf’. After that the ground surface cut up and the Saints improved. Premonitions of Moorabbin ‘local showers’ perhaps? For all their improved effort, the Saints couldn’t reflect their work on the scoreboard, whilst the well drilled Essendon outfit proved more adept at ‘opening up their forward precinct’.

For the Same Olds, the Armstrong brothers were at it yet again, Lou kicking 3 goals, Bert 2. Paddy Shea also contributed 3, whilst Ernie Cameron, Wally Chalmers and Fred Baring were ‘conspicuous’. For the Saints, the familiar names of Harry Lever, Bert Pierce and Artie Thomas fought the good fight, assisted by Gordon Dangerfield and Tom Baird.

Fitzroy’s loss saw them slip from second to fifth on the ladder, with South climbing to third and Collingwood to second.

 

Fitzroy 1.1   1.1   1.4   3.5 23 Mon 05-Jun-1911  Venue: Brunswick St
South Melbourne 2.4   6.6   6.7 10.11 71 South Melbourne won by 48 points
Geelong 2.1   3.3   7.5   7.7 49 Venue: Corio Oval
Carlton 1.3   4.3   4.5   5.8 38 Geelong won by 11 points
Collingwood 2.10  3.12  7.16 10.17 77 Venue: Victoria Park
University 2.0   4.3   5.5   7.9 51 Collingwood won by 28 points
Melbourne 3.3   3.6   5.9  6.12 48 Venue: MCG
Richmond 3.3  5.10  6.11  9.15 69 Richmond won by 21 points
Essendon 4.2   5.3   7.6  9.10 64 Venue: East Melbourne
St Kilda 0.1   1.3   1.4   3.6 24 Essendon won by 40 points

 

Rd 7 Ladder
ES 7 26 211.1
CW 7 20 98.6
SM 7 18 158.0
CA 7 16 120.6
FI 7 16 117.1
GE 7 14 91.9
RI 7 12 78.8
ME 7 10 87.4
UN 7 4 65.5
SK 7 4 54.1

 


 

 

Sources:

 

The Argus

AFL Tables

In The Blood: Jim Main

Fallen, The Ultimate Heroes: Jim Main & David Allen

Encyclopedia of AFL/VFL Footballers: Russell Holmesby & Jim Main

Wikipedia

 


 


About John Butler

John Butler has fled the World's Most Liveable Car Park and now breathes the rarefied air of the Ballarat Plateau. For his sins, he has been a Carlton member for more than 30 years.

Comments

  1. HERITAGE GIGSTUFF

    Great stuff, JB. Another thrilling week of footy, 1911 style. And from the files of Great-Grandad-Gigs, I can tell you that after the King’s Birthday Round, the Score Wars battle was being lead by 42 and 65, each having been scored four times to date in 1911. Just behind on three were 43, 45, 49, 54, 66 and the perennially popular 69.

    In the Marginal Medal, 0 (i.e. the draw) was equal leader on 3, just as it is in 2011 after the Queen’s Birthday. 26 points had also been a margin three times to this point.

    And the 9.10 (64) final score registered by Essendon was the first time the “Same Olds” had ever recorded this score. They wouldn’t do so again until 1922.

    Finally, even though John Phillip Sousa invented his own instrument, the Sousaphone, his name is an anagram of JOSH’S UPHILL PIANO.

  2. John Butler says:

    Gigs, your talents span the centuries. :)

  3. Thanks, JB. Unfortunately, my waistline is dangerously close to doing the same (in centimetres).

  4. John Butler says:

    I know something about that problem Gigs. :(

Leave a Comment

*